On a quiet stretch of East Superior Street, just past 18th Avenue East in Duluth, Minnesota, the gray stone walls and tall stained glass of St. Paul's Episcopal Church have welcomed worshippers for more than a century. The building went up between 1912 and 1914, but the congregation's life stretches back much further, and the community that gathers here today sees itself as a meeting place of ancient Christian tradition and the questions of contemporary life. St. Paul's calls itself "a place for everyone," and the parish is known across the Twin Ports for joyful, traditional worship, an award-winning music program, a deep commitment to children and youth, and an open door to LGBTQIA+ people, interfaith couples, and anyone else who has ever wondered whether they belonged.
A Congregation Older Than Its Building
The first prayer service on record at St. Paul's took place on August 5, 1866, just a few years after the city of Duluth took shape on the western tip of Lake Superior. The original frame church stood at 209 North Lake Avenue, Downtown, and was finished in 1869. The community grew with the city, and in 1881, when a typhoid outbreak swept Duluth, the women of the parish decided that something had to be done. They rallied the Vestry to found a hospital, formed a Board of Directors, and launched what would become St. Luke's Hospital. Not willing to wait for funds, the women rented a blacksmith's shop, scrubbed and painted it themselves, and within weeks had a twelve-bed facility running under the care of a single nurse and the rector, who tended patients three nights a week. By 1884 the operation had moved to a larger building with thirty-eight beds, and in 1902 a new St. Luke's opened on 9th and 1st Street, where the hospital remains. St. Paul's continued to direct St. Luke's until 1925, when the two became separate institutions. The story is still told inside the parish as a parable of what determined laypeople can do when a community is hurting.
By the early twentieth century the original wood frame church on Lake Avenue had outlived its usefulness, and the present stone sanctuary on East Superior Street was constructed between 1912 and 1914. The parish house followed in 1929, and the lower-level hall has since hosted bazaars, neighborhood meetings, wedding receptions, scout gatherings, and many of the social-justice projects the parish is known for today. The parish published a detailed centennial history in 1969, and continues to add chapters as it works through its archives.
Worship: Ancient Words, Joyful Noise
Worship at St. Paul's is rooted in the Episcopal tradition's Book of Common Prayer, the same prayer book used in Episcopal churches across the country and Anglican churches around the world. The rhythm is ancient, but the spirit is anything but stuffy. Each week, the community stands and kneels, makes the sign of the cross at times, sings together, breathes together, and walks forward for communion. People participate in different ways. Some kneel, some stand, some sit. All are welcome at their own comfort level.
There are two Sunday services, both held in English. At 8:00 am, the smaller Rite I service takes place in the chapel. It is quiet, contemplative, and uses the traditional language of the Book of Common Prayer. There is no music. At 10:00 am, the full Rite II service fills the sanctuary. It is described by the parish as "boisterous, joyful, and thoughtful." The service includes traditional hymns, anthems from the chancel choir, music from the handbell choir, and offerings from the children and youth of the parish. Communion is celebrated every week at both services, and all who wish to receive are welcome.
On Wednesdays during the academic year, the parish gathers again at 5:15 pm for a simple, spoken Eucharist in the sanctuary. The service is Rite II, informal, and includes a practice the parish calls "Dwelling in the Word," a small-group discussion of the scripture readings that will appear in the coming Sunday's lectionary. Communion is offered, the doors open at 5:05 pm, and the gathering is small enough that regulars greet one another by name.
St. Paul's follows the Revised Common Lectionary, the three-year cycle of scripture readings shared with Lutherans, Presbyterians, Methodists, United Church of Christ congregations, Roman Catholics, and others. The result, the parish notes, is that on any given Sunday, Christians from many traditions across Duluth and around the world are reading the same texts. The lectionary pulls together an Old Testament reading, a Psalm, an Epistle, and a Gospel for each week, and over three years walks through a generous cross-section of the Bible.
What Communion Looks Like at St. Paul's
Communion, or the Eucharist, is the center of the Episcopal service. St. Paul's practices open communion: every person who wishes to receive is welcome, without exception. The bread is received in the hand, and the wine may be taken either by drinking from the common cup or by dipping the bread into the cup. Low-gluten wafers are available on request. For those who would rather not receive wine, it is customary to receive only the bread. Anyone who would like a blessing instead of communion is invited to come forward with arms crossed over the chest, and a chalice bearer will offer the traditional words. Children may receive communion at any age; there is no formal First Communion ritual in the Episcopal tradition, and parents are trusted to know when their child is ready.
Ushers are present at every service to greet newcomers, hand out service leaflets or bulletins, and assist with seating. They can also signal communion servers to come to anyone with mobility needs who cannot walk to the front of the church.
Children and Youth at the Center
Children and young people are not an afterthought at St. Paul's; they are a reason the parish exists. The 10:00 am service has long been designed so that families can worship together without having to choose between their own spiritual life and their children's. "Joyful noise is most welcome here," the parish writes, and families are encouraged to sit up front so children can see and engage with the service. A staffed nursery is available for infants and toddlers, and a children's chapel called Godly Play meets during the 10:00 am service throughout the school year for children in kindergarten through sixth grade.
Godly Play is a Montessori-based storytelling curriculum built around wonder. Each week, children gather in rooms above the sanctuary, hear a core story of scripture told with wooden figures, and then spend time in "wondering," a practice of asking open questions and listening for what emerges. In alternate weeks they respond with art supplies, Legos, books, and figures. The parish keeps a K-3 room and a 3-6 room, with a soft boundary at third grade so that older children can self-select the space where they fit. Each room is led by two adults trained in Safe Church practices.
Older children have their own pathways. The "4 to 6" meets once a month on third Wednesdays from 4:00 to 6:00 pm for students in grades four through six, then joins the 5:15 pm Wednesday Eucharist and supper. An upper youth group for grades seven and up meets on first and third Wednesdays from 6:30 to 8:00 pm, following a progressive, scripture-based curriculum called Follow Me and walking students toward Confirmation. Each teen in the program is given an NRSV Bible at the start of the year as a kind of first "grown-up" Bible. About three-quarters of the youth at St. Paul's serve as acolytes, carrying the processional cross and candles, helping set the Eucharistic table, and supporting baptisms. They close the year with a celebration of their own.
Younger children are also paired with prayer partners from among the parish's elders, a tradition that has shaped relationships across generations for years. The children make cards and small gifts for the parish's homebound members, and once a month a Kids' Coffee Hour spills out into the lower level after church, with songs, games, and treats. In the summer, the parish sometimes brings Godly Play into the sanctuary as the first lesson, and the wider community enjoys the annual Blessing of the Animals, when pets on leashes and in crates join the 10:00 am service for a St. Francis of Assisi blessing.
Music as a Community Practice
Music at St. Paul's is not a performance; it is a community practice. The whole congregation sings several hymns at every 10:00 am service, and the music is deliberately diverse. The chancel choir, led by the Minister of Music, sings anthems drawn from across the global Anglican Communion, including traditional spirituals sung a cappella, music from the Caribbean and Africa, and contemporary settings. The handbell choir rings once a month or so, sometimes joined by a brass ensemble, percussion, or classical guitar. The church's organ is played by talented organists from the parish, including organ students learning the craft.
Children and teens regularly share their musical gifts during worship, and the parish's music director, Dr. Thomas Hamilton, also teaches private piano lessons in the building and runs a Kindermusik program for pre-K children. Rehearsals for the chancel choir take place on Wednesday evenings at 6:15 pm in the sanctuary, with the handbell choir following at 7:30 pm. Both are open to new members, and anyone interested in joining can reach out to Dr. Hamilton directly.
Wednesday Nights: Eucharist, Supper, and the Hard Questions
Wednesday evenings are the second rhythm of parish life at St. Paul's. The week begins with the 5:15 pm spoken Eucharist, then unfolds around a shared meal. On the first and third Wednesdays of the month during the school year, the parish serves a home-cooked supper at 6:00 pm in the parish hall, prepared by members of the congregation. Donations are accepted, but the meal is free. At 6:30 pm, the community splits into a forum for adults, a Confirmation preparation class for high schoolers in grades nine through twelve, and the upper youth group.
The adult forum has historically explored how the saints of the Christian tradition might speak into current life, a series the parish calls "Our Faithful Ancestors: Saints for Our Times." Past evenings have featured figures like Francis of Assisi, Hildegard of Bingen, Luke, Pauli Murray, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Enmegahbowh, the nineteenth-century Ojibwe elder who is the only saint in the Episcopal calendar whose ministry was primarily in Minnesota. On fifth Wednesdays, the parish gathers for a themed potluck. Harvest potlucks in late September have featured a talk on restoring local wild rice habitat, and the gatherings are open to all without RSVP.
Thursday mornings, a multi-week program called Practicing the Way of Jesus meets at 10:00 am in the parish hall. It is a small-group journey through the spiritual practices of the Christian life, beginning in the fall and running into early December, with coffee and fellowship built in. There is no cost to participate.
Adults, Small Groups, and Bible Study
St. Paul's is, in its own description, "a community that loves to learn." Adult formation takes several forms. A weekly Bible study meets Friday mornings at 10:00 am in the Olcott Room, currently working through the Book of Revelation. Book studies and Christian spirituality small groups rotate seasonally, with new groups forming about four times a year. Each fall, a New Member Cohort runs over four Sundays at 11:30 am for people considering formally joining the parish, with shared lunch and conversation about why people are drawn to St. Paul's, what they believe about Jesus, and what church membership means in their lives. Childcare is arranged on request, and a liturgy of welcome is held at the end of the cohort in late October or early November.
The parish publishes a monthly newsletter called The Messenger, mailed to households and available online, which carries the most up-to-date information on formation offerings, parish events, and lay ministry schedules. Each issue also carries a sermon reflection, a calendar of coming events, and an invitation to the next major parish gathering.
A Welcoming and Affirming Community
St. Paul's has long been a parish where people who felt they did not fit elsewhere could find a home. The parish is explicit in its welcome to LGBTQIA+ people, couples, and families. The rector, the Rev. Maggie Nancarrow, preached the September 6, 2026 Ecumenical Pride Sunday sermon on the story of Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch, an ancient figure whose baptism, the rector argued, is scripture's clearest foundation for the full inclusion of gender-nonconforming people in the life of the church. Several local churches gather for a single joint Pride worship service each year, with St. Paul's, Peace UCC, the Unitarians of Duluth, Pilgrim Congregational, and others joining together for one Episcopal-rooted service.
The parish marries straight, gay, lesbian, and queer couples, and expects that those seeking marriage there are known to the congregation. It blesses existing civil unions and civil marriages, including those of previously divorced persons (with the bishop's permission as a formality). The youth curriculum includes affirming and theologically grounded conversations about gender expression, sexual orientation, and sexuality.
Families of all configurations sit in the pews: two moms, two dads, single parents, blended families, grandparents raising grandkids, and single adults. The parish's Iona Community invitation is read at communion each week: "Come to this table, you who have much faith, and you who can find none today. You who have been to this sacrament often, and you who have not been in a long time. You who have tried to follow Jesus, and you who have failed. Come. It is Christ who invites us to meet him here."
The Building and Accessibility
The sanctuary on East Superior Street is wheelchair accessible from the Greysolon Road entrance, and an elevator serves three levels: the parish hall on the lower level, the parish offices on the first floor, and the sanctuary on the second. Wheelchair seating is available in the front and middle sections of the sanctuary, and ushers can bring communion to anyone unable to come forward. A single-user, all-gender restroom is located at the end of the hall on the first floor, and accessible restrooms are available on the lower level.
Parking is straightforward. A parking lot sits off Greysolon Road, with three handicap parking spaces on the street and a smaller lot off Superior Street with another accessible space. Street parking is available on Superior Street and the surrounding blocks, and on Sunday mornings visitors may also use the small lot behind the yellow house next door. From the parking lot, two flights of stairs or the elevator lead to the sanctuary, and the office entrance near the Celtic Garden provides an alternative route to the chapel on Level 1.
The parish is currently in the middle of a major capital campaign called Building Our Legacy, a five-year effort to repair and modernize the building for the next generation. Three priority projects are underway: tuckpointing the east and north exterior walls and Superior Street entrances, restoring the historic pipe organ (some of whose pipes have stopped playing), and replacing the thirty-year-old elevator. A stretch phase will then upgrade the heating system, restore the sanctuary's interior plaster and paint, and improve overall energy efficiency. The campaign goal is $1,300,000, with a stretch goal of $2,000,000 and a challenge goal of $2,600,000.
Service Beyond the Walls
St. Paul's has always understood itself as a parish with a responsibility to the city around it. Members serve lunch regularly at the Damiano Center, the long-running Catholic Worker house that operates one of Duluth's main community kitchens. They volunteer with Laundry Love, providing the dignity of clean clothes to neighbors who cannot afford the laundromat. They support Chum, SafeHaven, LifeHouse, Habitat for Humanity, and the Loaves and Fishes Catholic Worker House. The parish has also given directly to Casa Maria in Richfield and to the Migrant Support Fund established by the Episcopal bishop of Minnesota in 2025 to assist immigrants across the state.
On Easter Sunday 2026, the parish took its entire non-pledge collection for a special offering to Undue Medical Debt. St. Paul's raised more than $25,000, and through Undue's bulk purchase of bundled medical debt on the secondary market, the parish was able to abolish $3,235,613.81 in medical debt for 3,693 households across St. Louis, Carlton, Itasca, Lake, and Douglas Counties. Most of those households were in St. Louis County, where Duluth sits. The letters went out in June 2026, each one explaining that a gift from St. Paul's had made the erasure possible.
Faith and the Lake
The parish is also a community that takes its geography seriously. Lake Superior Sunday, held in mid-July each year, is an outdoor service on the beach at Park Point, hosted jointly with St. Andrew's Episcopal Church and built around gratitude for water. The parish has hosted beach clean-ups with its youth, supported Hands Across Duluth's youth service camp, and explored themes of faith and ecology in its preaching. Many of the lay leaders are scientists, outdoor enthusiasts, and parents thinking about what kind of future they are leaving for their children. The result is a parish that does not separate its spiritual life from its care for the watershed it lives beside.
The St. Paul's Scholarship Fund
Education has been part of the parish's vocation since the founding of St. Luke's Hospital, and the Mars family has established a permanent Scholarship Fund at St. Paul's to support post-secondary education for members of the parish. Graduating high school seniors and high school graduates of any age are eligible. Awards are renewable for up to four academic years, and the application process opens each winter. Recipients are chosen by a committee of parish and family members based on active participation in the life of the church, demonstrated interest in completing a degree or trade program, and submitted recommendations.
The Clergy and Staff
The Rev. Maggie Nancarrow has served as rector since being ordained to the priesthood in Minneapolis in June 2020. She holds a Master of Divinity from the University of Chicago and a Bachelor of Arts in Religion and History from Hamline University, and completed her Anglican formation in the Episcopal Church in Minnesota's cohort program. Before becoming rector, she spent eight years in ministry with children and youth, and her primary interests are the spirituality of wilderness, the cultivation of faith communities as places of social connectedness, and making the ancient stories of the Bible accessible to contemporary hearers. She is an avid cyclist, hiker, climber, and camper.
The Rev. Patricia Benson, the parish's deacon, came to St. Paul's forty years ago for a Search retreat and brought her younger two children back for a Teens Encounter Christ retreat in the past decade. She became an empty nester in 2020, downsized to Duluth, and now serves as deacon, walking with the parish into its next chapter.
Dr. Thomas Hamilton, the Minister of Music, grew up in Hibbing, where his father was a teacher and house manager of the high school auditorium. He developed his lifelong fascination with the organ in those halls and brings that range of sound to St. Paul's. He teaches private piano lessons, leads the chancel choir and handbell choir, and serves as a contact for anyone interested in joining a musical ensemble.
Sophie Gray is the Faith Formation Coordinator, overseeing the children's, youth, and family ministries. A southern Minnesota native who has lived in South Minneapolis, Galway, and East Tennessee before settling in Duluth, she is a graduate of St. Peter's Episcopal in Kasson and brings a passion for inclusivity into her work with the parish's youngest members.
Rita Rosenberger has been a member of St. Paul's since 2005 and serves as Parish Administrator. She and her husband David Barthel have two college students, and she sings in the chancel choir and handbell choir. Christine Melone is the bookkeeper. The parish's unofficial greeter is a nine-year-old Goldendoodle named Kofi, who spends weekdays in the parish office and is known for his calm, friendly welcome.
How to Find St. Paul's
The church sits at 1710 E Superior Street, Duluth, Minnesota 55812, just past 18th Avenue East. From the expressway, take Exit 35N at 21st Avenue East, turn left onto Superior Street, and the church will be on the left. The parish office is open Monday through Friday from 9:00 am to 1:30 pm (some sources note 8:30 am), Saturday by appointment, and Sunday mornings from 8:00 am to 11:30 am. The phone number is 218-724-3535, and the office can be reached at office@stpaulsduluth.org. The rector can be reached at rector@stpaulsduluth.org, the deacon at deacon@stpaulsduluth.org, the music office at music@stpaulsduluth.org, and the bookkeeper at bookkeeper@stpaulsduluth.org. Sunday worship is livestreamed on the parish's YouTube channel, and recordings of recent sermons are available there as well, going back several years.
St. Paul's has been on East Superior Street since 1914, but the community that gathers there keeps tracing the same arc: a people shaped by ancient Christian worship, gathered around a common table, asking the hard questions, and looking for a way to live generously in the city that surrounds them. Whether the visitor comes for the 8:00 am chapel service, the 10:00 am sung Eucharist, the Wednesday night supper, the children's Godly Play room, or a quiet conversation with a deacon, the welcome at the red doors is the same. There is a place for everyone here, and the church means it.