St Matthew Lutheran Church sits on the north side of Port Washington, a Lake Michigan town in Ozaukee County, Wisconsin, at 1525 N Grant Street. As a member congregation of the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS), St. Matthew shares the historic Lutheran confession that salvation is the gift of God by grace alone, through faith alone, on the authority of Scripture alone. The people who gather here describe themselves as ordinary - some married, some single, some young, some older, from a wide mix of backgrounds - united by a common faith in a God who loved the world by sending his Son.
A New Start in the KC Hall
St. Matthew began on November 4, 1979, when 24 adults gathered for the first service. They chose the name "St. Matthew" (without the possessive apostrophe-s) on purpose: the congregation does not belong to Matthew, but to Jesus and his people.
The new group rented the Knights of Columbus Hall in downtown Port Washington, a building originally constructed in 1845 by a group of Methodists who worshipped there until their congregation dissolved in 1912. Retired WELS District President Adolph Buenger canvassed the neighborhoods and tracked down Wisconsin Synod families who had moved into the area, but heart trouble kept him off the pulpit. Professors Jeske and Balge from Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary in Mequon rotated as preachers in those first months.
Growth came quickly once a full-time pastor arrived. In the spring of 1980, seminary graduate Dan Simons was assigned to the call, and the congregation's reputation spread. St. Matthew was featured in the WELS magazine Northwestern Lutheran (now Forward in Christ) and on a special WELS Missions Calendar.
The Building on Grant Street
In 1982, the young congregation purchased land on the north side of town. Members were told that the street immediately to the south, Norport, would eventually extend westward, putting the new property on a main thoroughfare. That extension never came, but the location has stayed. The church building was dedicated in 1985, and in 1988 the footprint doubled when an addition was built for a preschool and child care program. The vast majority of children enrolled came from outside the congregation, and over the years several of those families joined St. Matthew.
In the early 2010s, the local school district planned to start its own preschool and approached St. Matthew about renting space. The conversation ended when the city asked the church to restrict "Jesus time" to the first and last fifteen minutes of each day so families could opt out. St. Matthew could not agree to those terms. Enrollment struggled, and the child care program was reluctantly closed in the spring of 2016. In the spring of 2025, the congregation completed a full remodel of the fellowship hall: a larger doorway, softer colors, a more spacious layout, and a prominent coffee bar designed to give members and visitors a more inviting place to gather between services.
Three Pastors, One Mission
Pastor Simons accepted a call to Historic Salem in February 1990. That July, Pastor Don Thompson accepted the call to Port Washington and continued the spirit of outreach, including launching the prison ministry that continues today at the Ozaukee County jail on the south side of the city. A Wisconsin Synod pastor has always led that ministry, with most preaching and teaching done by WELS people.
Pastor Thompson took a call to Jupiter, Florida, in June 2001. Pastor Martin Wildauer accepted the call and was installed on September 9, 2001, two days before 9/11. A graduate of Northwestern College in Watertown, Wisconsin, and Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary in Mequon, where he earned his M. Div., Pastor Wildauer had previously served congregations in Beckley, West Virginia, and New Carlisle, Ohio. He and his wife, Teri, have five children. Members of St. Matthew have walked in the city's Fish Day and Christmas parades under his leadership, and the congregation's relationship with Port Washington has deepened over more than two decades.
Sundays on Grant Street
Sunday brings the busiest day of the week. Two identical worship services take place at 8:00 a.m. and 10:30 a.m. Each service lasts about an hour and uses a variety of formats with music both old and new. Worship is thought of as a conversation with God: bringing troubles to him and hearing what he has done and will continue to do. Communion is offered on the first, third, and (when applicable) fifth Sundays of the month in all services, using individual cups along with the common cup.
At 9:15 a.m., between the two services, Bible Study and Sunday School meet at the same hour. Bible Study rotates between sections of the Bible and relevant topics; Sunday School gathers children of all ages around the same lessons. A cry room is located in the back of the sanctuary with a window into the worship space. The room has rocking chairs, a changing table, books, toys, and a sound system so parents don't miss a word of the service. Anyone is welcome to use the room when little ones get restless.
Monday Evenings on Grant Street
Monday is for digging in as well. Bible Class meets in the Luther Room at 10:00 a.m., and a Monday evening worship service is held at 6:30 p.m. The 8:00 a.m. Sunday service and the Wednesday 6:30 p.m. services during Lent are livestreamed on the congregation's YouTube channel, where alerts can be turned on for new videos.
Close Communion and the Lord's Supper
St. Matthew practices close communion. Members of the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod and the Evangelical Lutheran Synod are welcome at the Lord's Supper, which the congregation believes brings believers close to Jesus and expresses closeness to one another. Visitors who are not in fellowship with WELS or ELS are warmly invited to speak with the pastor before communing; he is happy to visit about what the sacrament means.
Reaching Beyond the Walls
Outreach has long been part of St. Matthew's identity. The prison ministry that Pastor Thompson launched in the early 1990s is still going, with weekly preaching and teaching at the Ozaukee County facility by WELS pastors and laypeople. The church building hosts community blood drives and serves as a polling place on election days. Members participate in Port Washington's Fish Day and Christmas parades. The congregation has also worked with Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary's Early Field Training program and has hosted vicars with special circumstances.
In a quiet act of stewardship in 2002, a member of St. Matthew spotted that the old Friedens church, built by the first Lutheran families in Port Washington in the late 1850s, was on fire and called for help, helping to save a building that still stands in town.
Schools They Support
St. Matthew takes seriously the Lutheran tradition of Christian schooling from kindergarten through college. The congregation actively supports:
- Wisconsin Lutheran College, a WELS-affiliated liberal arts college of about 1,200 students on the border of Milwaukee and Wauwatosa.
- Martin Luther College, a private WELS college in New Ulm, Minnesota, that trains pastors, teachers, and staff ministers.
- Our Savior Lutheran School in Grafton, Wisconsin, a Christian school family serving preschool (3K and 4K) through grade 8.
- Kettle Moraine Lutheran High School, a four-year Lutheran high school in the Town of Jackson.
- Wisconsin Lutheran High School, a private preparatory high school in Milwaukee.
What St. Matthew Believes
St. Matthew confesses Jesus Christ as the only Savior from sin and the only hope for eternal life. The congregation believes that all of the Bible is the true Word of God and is never wrong, and that the Bible is the final authority for Christian teaching and life. The congregation subscribes to the Lutheran Confessions as compiled in the Book of Concord of 1580 (the Apostles' Creed, the Nicene Creed, the Athanasian Creed, the Small Catechism, the Large Catechism, the Augsburg Confession, the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, the Smalcald Articles, and the Formula of Concord) and belongs to the worldwide fellowship of WELS believers.
First-Time Visitors
St. Matthew welcomes anyone, including children of all ages, to its worship services. There is no cost to attend and guests are never expected to contribute when the offering plates are passed. Members give their offerings so the congregation can continue sharing the good news of forgiveness in Jesus Christ.
There is no dress code. The church asks only that visitors come as they are; what matters is not what is worn but the welcome that follows.
Several handicapped parking spaces sit close to the church entrance, and visitor parking is located between those spaces and the street side of the lot. Large print editions of the service are available so anyone can follow along. For those who are hard of hearing, hearing devices can be requested from an usher. The cry room in the back of the sanctuary gives parents a place to step away with little ones while still hearing every word.
The mission statement sums up the heart of the place: To shine the light of God's Word to make and strengthen disciples of Jesus Christ. Online giving is available for those who wish to support that mission.