Need a website or online shop for your business? GetYourSite builds them from $24.99/month. Any small business · Half price for the first year, normally $49.99/month · Get 50% off

Rooted, Relevant, and Relational: Holy Cross Lutheran Church in Menomonee Falls

Lutheran Church in Trumbull, Connecticut

Holy Cross Lutheran Church in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, is an ELCA congregation of more than 1,500 members with Saturday and Sunday worship, a preschool and school on the same campus, and ministries spanning faith formation, music, recovery support and mission partnerships in Milwaukee, Tanzania and El Salvador.

About Holy Cross Lutheran Church

Holy Cross Lutheran Church stands at W156 N8131 Pilgrim Road in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, where a multigenerational congregation of more than 1,500 members gathers for worship three times each weekend and runs a preschool and school alongside its sanctuary. The church's motto, Rooted, Relevant, Relational, describes a congregation that pairs weekly worship and a long roster of ministries with an emphatic welcome: people of every race, background, ability, age, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, and social status are invited to be fully known and loved. Holy Cross is a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and its Greater Milwaukee Synod, and it carries its faith into partnerships in Milwaukee, Tanzania and El Salvador.

Rooted, Relevant, and Relational on Pilgrim Road

Holy Cross says its faith is firmly planted in the Gospel, reflected in its worship and sacraments, and full of God's grace. Scripture is read to find meaning in the ways God shows up in daily life and to work out how people can serve others, and the church holds that God is still speaking as it connects faith to life. The congregation calls itself a multigenerational community bonded by faithful engagement and growing together to transform the world around it.

Welcome is not a side note here. Holy Cross calls itself a safe space to be fully known and loved, celebrates differences instead of smoothing them over, and names LGBTQIA+ siblings and community among those it wants to embrace. Its mission is outward: to be the light of the world that dispels hatred, prejudice and selfishness, to live the commandment to love a neighbor as oneself, and to seek social and economic justice while combating racism and discrimination. The congregation's own description is short and direct: all are welcome, just as you are.

Justice work is carried by named teams. The Really Inclusive Church team works actively toward an inclusive environment for people who are marginalized because of sexual orientation, gender identity or other identities, and the Adventures in Renewal team works to draw the wider congregation into Spirit-led renewal. A GLOCAL team frames the outward work as lifelong growth in faith and service through encounters across racial, cultural, economic and geographic differences, connecting the church's resources to people and places that need help.

The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, one of the largest Christian denominations in the United States with nearly 3.3 million members in more than 8,900 worshipping communities across the 50 states and the Caribbean, provides the wider setting for the congregation's life. Its Greater Milwaukee Synod covers an area from Kenosha north to Sheboygan and west to Ixonia, with 118 congregations, three Synod-Authorized Worshipping Communities and an active campus ministry.

Three Gatherings Each Weekend

Holy Cross worships on Saturday at 5:00 pm and on Sunday at 8:00 am and 9:30 am. Both Sunday services are livestreamed and held in person, and the livestream runs to the congregation's YouTube channel and Facebook page every Sunday. Replays are archived as soon as a service ends in a Worship Services playlist on YouTube, so a member who misses a gathering can still hear the sermon and the music afterward. Watch the services online.

All ages gather for worship at any of the three services. The music program is substantial, with a principal organist at the center of it, a Chancel Choir, a Celebration Band and a children's choir. The congregation is also raising money to replace aging lighting and install a new organ so that the music ministry can explore a wider range of musical expression and inspire worship for years to come.

Faith development instruction for children from 3 years old through sixth grade is offered at the 9:30 am service during the school year. Children begin in the sanctuary with their families or guardians, head to their classrooms after the children's message, and are picked up there after worship concludes.

Faith Development, Confirmation, and Thursday Mornings

Holy Cross calls its Sunday school Faith Development, and the name matches the goal: to help children from 3 years old through sixth grade discover who God is, to find God's story in Scripture, and to affirm each child as a child of God. Faith Development runs from the weekend after Labor Day through May, matching the school year, and classes use the 9:30 am worship hour so that families stay together for music and message before children move to classrooms.

Students in seventh and eighth grade move on to Midweek Discipleship, the church's name for confirmation. It is a two-year journey in which young people affirm the promises of their baptism, take ownership of their faith journey and make a public profession of faith.

Adults have two recurring study opportunities. Dwelling in the Word meets on Thursdays at 10 am to discuss the scriptures that will be preached over the weekend. TT@T, or Third Thursday at Ten, is an educational gathering with guest speakers and a variety of topics that meets on the third Thursday of each month. The aim of the whole formation program is straightforward: that every baptized child of God develops a relationship with Jesus Christ and knows God's boundless love and grace through everyday life.

Organ, Chancel Choir, and the Celebration Band

Music carries a large share of Holy Cross's identity. Minister of Music Mike Jacklin coordinates the music program, serves as principal organist and oversees the choirs. With more than 40 years as a Lutheran church musician and study at the Chicago Conservatory of Music and with Dr. Mark Russakoff, he has composed and arranged more than 100 pieces, conducted benefit concerts and works on historical theater pipe organs through the Dairyland Theater Organ Society.

Assistant Minister of Music Karen Heins leads the Celebration Band and the children's choir and assists the other choirs. A graduate of Stritch University with a degree in music education, she joined Holy Cross in 1995, has held a range of music leadership roles, and enjoys leading diverse worship styles with people of all ages. She also sings with the Milwaukee Symphony Chorus. Phil Smith, a member since 1998 and a graduate of Carroll University in music and business, serves as Chancel Choir accompanist and works for the Greater Milwaukee Synod of the ELCA.

The next step for the ministry is a new organ and new sanctuary lighting. The campaign is framed as more than replacing aging equipment: it is meant to give the music ministry room to grow, explore a wider range of musical expression and inspire worship for years to come.

A School That Grows Alongside the Church

Holy Cross Lutheran School includes Holy Cross Preschool, and the two share a campus with the sanctuary. Tammy Seidemann serves as head of school, overseeing staff, learning programs, child safety and fundraising, and moved into the role in 2019 after many years as a 4K teacher. Brittney Rasmussen has taught the 3K class since 2016 and holds a bachelor's degree in early childhood-elementary education. First-year teacher Katherine Seidemann graduated from Winona State University with a degree in cell and molecular biology and is a lifelong member of the church.

Learning here is hands-on. Preschool classes raised monarch butterflies and released them in early June, and Vacation Bible School has traveled to Hephatha Lutheran Church in Milwaukee for a day of learning about the partnership between the two congregations and about Juneteenth. Each year the church also recruits teachers and helpers for Faith Development.

Partners in Milwaukee, Tanzania, and El Salvador

Holy Cross's outward work runs through long relationships. Locally, the church partners with All Peoples and Hephatha Lutheran Churches in Milwaukee. One Saturday a month, Holy Cross volunteers serve taco lunches at Hephatha, and Vacation Bible School has made its way there to learn about the partnership and Juneteenth. The congregation's Share Our Best team has found a new place to store furniture that then goes to homes in need, and the church has also gathered for Praise in the Park, an outdoor celebration of Jesus.

Globally, Holy Cross names its friends at Seela Parish in the Meru Diocese of Tanzania and Manantiales del Desierto (Springs in the Desert) in El Salvador as partners in mission. At home, the church supports and collaborates with the Menomonee Falls Food Pantry, Lutheran Social Services, Outreach for Hope, NAMI and The Healing Network.

Service at Holy Cross is distributed among many teams. Alongside the mission partners, members move and deliver furniture for Share Our Best, serve as lectors, ushers and greeters in worship, drive and serve taco lunches, give blood at a recurring drive, and join a group that meets for coffee in the courtyard after worship. The church also shares stories of congregational generosity and service, including teen hangouts where friendships and faith are built together and youth groups having summer fun.

The Healing Network: Conversation, Resources, and Recovery Support

The Healing Network at Holy Cross brings faith communities together around a shared vision of healing for people who struggle with addiction and substance misuse. The network describes itself as an authentic and inclusive community seeking healing together, and its work includes space for conversation, resources for prevention and awareness education, early intervention, referral, recovery support and advocacy, all guided by faith.

Holy Cross hosts regular recovery meetings, including an AA Monday Night Action Group, a T.O.P.S. meeting and the Terrific Tuesday Big Book Meeting. For families, the Healing Network has published practical guidance on raising concern about alcohol use with a loved one, with scripts to rehearse, advice on choosing a calm time and place, and ways to agree on one measurable change and a date to talk again.

The resource collection is both practical and wide-ranging. It includes a reference list for struggling veterans with crisis lines and support organizations, a guided meditation titled You Are a Gift, an essay called Heaven Looks Like Us on being Black in a majority white culture and mental health, a guide to assessing memory loss and when to seek help, and a review of common problems veterans face after leaving military service.

Men in Mission, TOPS, and the Groups That Fill the Week

Holy Cross's regular gatherings extend well beyond Sunday. Men in Mission, a men's ministry of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, meets every third Saturday of the month from 8:00 to 9:00 am. The program helps men build trusting relationships with other Christian men and is deliberately open and non-threatening to men who are not churched.

Other recurring gatherings include the Monday night AA group, T.O.P.S., the Terrific Tuesday Big Book Meeting, a quilting group, a Strong Bodies fitness gathering, a Celebration Band rehearsal and a To Do Crew. A welcome gathering called Cross Training is built for newcomers, and the church's events, volunteer opportunities and giving are all coordinated through the Realm Connect app.

Baptism, Marriage, Funerals, and the Prayer Chain

Holy Cross walks with people through the sacraments and the turning points of life. In baptism, the church teaches that a gracious heavenly Father frees a person from sin and death by joining that person to the death and resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ, and it provides forms for both child and adult baptism. The church's ministers officiate weddings for members and non-members, with separate forms for each, and funeral planning is supported with a planning form. The congregation also maintains a prayer chain for those who want to add a prayer.

Pastoral Care and Leadership

Pastor Andy Fetters serves as Pastor of Discipleship and Faith Formation, leading the church's formation life from Faith Development through confirmation. He grew up in Columbus, Ohio, in a large family with foster and adopted siblings, worked in restaurants before ministry and moved to Wisconsin in 2012. He is married to Pastor Becky Fetters, and they have three children.

Pastor Jenny Nettesheim is the congregation's pastoral care coordinator. She was a school counselor for 19 years before beginning her seminary journey at Wartburg Theological Seminary, and she names the favorite part of ministry as getting to know people and building relationships with people of all ages. She believes God's love is expansive and inclusive of all people.

Finding Your Way to Pilgrim Road

Holy Cross is at W156 N8131 Pilgrim Road, Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin 53051-3728. Two parking lots serve the church: one immediately south of the building and one to the north, across the street on Robinhood Drive. Handicapped parking is in the south lot, the southeast entrance is accessible, and a handicapped-accessible restroom is located inside and to the right. The office is open Monday through Thursday from 9 am to 4 pm and Friday from 9 am to noon, and the church's phone number is (262) 251-2740.

Realm Connect: Giving, Directories, and Volunteers

Realm Connect, the app Holy Cross uses to schedule events, coordinate volunteer opportunities and send updates to the congregation, is available for iOS and Android through the church's download link. It carries an online membership directory, community features, giving, event registration and volunteer opportunities. New users receive an invitation, create a login, then adjust privacy settings and add the skills and interests that help the church connect people with service.

Giving can be made online through Realm, with recurring gifts set up in a member's Realm profile, or by text message to the church's Give+Text number, 262-592-4160. The Realm Connect app supports giving and recurring donations as well, and the church invites members to make a pledge for the coming year. Weekly newsletters, archived worship services and a busy calendar of gatherings keep the congregation connected between Sundays.

Holy Cross describes its own work with one line: growing disciples across all generations to do justice, welcome with love and serve humbly with God. On Pilgrim Road that work is carried by a large staff and a wide circle of volunteers, by a music program with a pipe organ at its center, by a preschool and school that share the grounds, and by partnerships that reach from Menomonee Falls and Milwaukee to Tanzania and El Salvador. It is a congregation that is rooted in the Gospel, relevant to the life of the community around it, and relational in the way it receives people and sends them back out to serve.

Frequently asked questions

When does Holy Cross hold worship services?

Saturday at 5:00 pm, Sunday at 8:00 am, and Sunday at 9:30 am. Both Sunday services are livestreamed and held in person.

Can I watch a service if I cannot attend?

Both Sunday services are livestreamed to the church's YouTube channel and Facebook page, and replays are archived immediately in the Worship Services playlist on YouTube.

What happens for children during worship?

Faith Development for children from 3 years old through sixth grade runs during the 9:30 am service in the school year. Children start in the sanctuary with their families, move to classrooms after the children's message, and are picked up there after worship.

Is there parking and accessibility at the church?

Two lots serve the church: one immediately south of the building and one north across the street on Robinhood Drive. Handicapped parking is in the south lot, the southeast entrance is accessible, and a handicapped-accessible restroom is inside and to the right.

Does Holy Cross run a school?

Yes. Holy Cross Lutheran School includes Holy Cross Preschool on the church campus, with 3K and 4K classes and staff who oversee learning programs, child safety and fundraising.

How can I give or volunteer?

Giving is available online through Realm, by text message to 262-592-4160, and through the Realm Connect app, which also lists volunteer opportunities and event registration.

What groups meet for adults and families?

Dwelling in the Word meets on Thursdays at 10 am, Men in Mission meets every third Saturday from 8:00 to 9:00 am, and the congregation also hosts a quilting group, a Celebration Band rehearsal and a gathering for newcomers called Cross Training.

Does the church host recovery meetings?

Yes. Holy Cross hosts an AA Monday Night Action Group, a T.O.P.S. meeting and the Terrific Tuesday Big Book Meeting, and its Healing Network provides resources for people affected by addiction and substance misuse.

Explore more churches

Looking somewhere else? Find churches near any ZIP code, city or address:

Plan your visit

Location on Map

Loading map…

Location Information

  • Address 5995 Main St, Trumbull, CT 06611
  • County Fairfield County
  • Area code 203
  • Time zone EST (observes DST)
  • PMSA 1160
  • FIPS 09001