Wesley United Methodist Church stands at the corner of Galena and May in Aurora, with roots among Methodists living on Aurora's west side of the Fox River. The congregation is known for its long history, its mission of making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world, and a church life that connects worship, reconciliation, education, care and service.
From the West Side of the Fox River to Galena and May
The story begins in 1850 when Methodists living on the west side of the Fox River decided to form a congregation. Their early names and locations trace a series of moves and mergers that eventually produced Wesley M.E. Church. The story also includes the Swedish Methodist congregation that became Locust Street Methodist Church, giving Wesley two congregational histories to join in 1948.
- 1850: Methodists living on Aurora's west side of the Fox River decided to form a west-side congregation.
- 1858: The congregation built a church north on Galena between Lake and River streets and named it Second M.E. Church.
- 1868: Thirty-nine people transferred from First M.E. Church to strengthen Second M.E. Church. The merged congregation met in the old Episcopal Church at Lake Street and Spruce.
- 1871: A new church on the south side of Galena at Locust brought the name Galena Street M.E. Church.
- 1884-1892: A Swedish Methodist Church organized in 1884, first meeting in a Main Street hall and later on Broadway. In 1887 it purchased the old German Methodist Church and moved it to Clark and Fourth. In 1892 it sold that building, bought property at Cedar and Locust, and became Locust Street Methodist Church.
- 1920 and 1929: Galena Street M.E. became Galena Boulevard M.E. Church in 1920. Ground was broken at Galena Boulevard and May Street in 1929, and the congregation took the name Wesley M.E. Church.
- 1930: The Education Building and Colwell Memorial Chapel were dedicated.
- 1942-1948: The Galena Boulevard M.E. church was sold in 1942. In 1948, Locust Street Methodist Church and Wesley M.E. Church merged and kept the Wesley name.
- 1952-1956: Fundraising for a sanctuary began in 1952, and the sanctuary of Wesley M.E. Church was dedicated in 1956.
- 1968: The Methodist church joined the Evangelical United Brethren to form The United Methodist Church, and Wesley became Wesley United Methodist Church.
These moves make the present congregation more than the story of one building. Its identity carries the names Second M.E., Galena Street, Locust Street, Wesley M.E., and Wesley United Methodist Church, together with the experience of two Aurora congregations choosing to become one. The Education Building, Colwell Memorial Chapel, and sanctuary remain part of that institutional memory. Wesley also connects its present purpose to John Wesley's emphasis on Christian living and the transformation of the world.
Sunday Worship at 9:30 Online and 10:30 in Person
Sunday has two clear worship times. Online worship begins at 9:30 a.m., while in-person worship begins at 10:30 a.m. Wesley's broader formation path places scripture, prayer, fasting, small groups, regular worship, sacraments, accountability, and healthy living within the means of grace described by John Wesley. A bell choir under the direction of Thew Elliott is part of the congregation's music ministry. Archived Sunday services extend back to January 2023 through the Sunday-service archive.
First-time visitors have clear entrance information. The church is at 14 N. May St., at Galena and May. The main entrance can be reached from the parking lot on Galena Boulevard. A ramp is located off New York Street, and a wheelchair lift is available off the parking lot. The main office phone is 630-896-1033. Office hours are 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Tuesday and Thursday and 9 a.m. to noon Wednesday.
Wesley has trained and screened staff and volunteers through Safe Gatherings. That care for safety accompanies a Reconciling identity, an emphasis on spiritual maturity, and a congregation that welcomes people into discussion and participation through many entry points for learning and fellowship.
Practical Divinity, Discipleship and Reconciliation
Wesley's stated mission is making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world. It describes itself as a Reconciling Congregation committed to building an all-inclusive Christian community from the heart of Aurora. The mission is joined to the heritage of John Wesley and the early Methodists, who placed primary emphasis on Christian living and on putting faith and love into action. Wesley calls this emphasis practical divinity and identifies it as a continuing hallmark of United Methodism.
The congregation also states its obligation to bear a faithful Christian witness to Jesus Christ, described as the living reality at the center of the church's life and witness. That witness includes critical reflection on the biblical and theological inheritance and an effort to express that faith faithfully in the present. The church's formation practices extend beyond worship itself to Scripture study, prayer, fasting, small groups, sacraments, accountability, healthy living, and participation in Core Principles classes.
Six Core Principles give practical shape to the mission. Together, they show that inclusion, hospitality, spiritual growth, responsibility, and justice are central to the life of the Wesley community.
- Seeing the image of God in all people: A follower of Jesus recognizes the sacred worth of each person, responds to that worth with respect, and desires better outcomes for individuals and families.
- Celebrating diversity and differences: The congregation encourages active listening and learning across cultures, with intentional inclusion of people of different ages, backgrounds, abilities, languages, faiths, political views, genders, sexual orientations, and marital statuses.
- Welcoming all people with radical hospitality: Welcoming others is an active practice. Members and friends are encouraged to take deliberate steps so that people feel welcomed, included, and accepted.
- Developing spiritual maturity: Wesley points to Scripture, prayer, fasting, small groups, worship, sacraments, accountability, healthy living, and Core Principles classes as practices that support continuing spiritual growth.
- Working toward excellence: People are encouraged to move beyond their comfort zones, respond faithfully to grace, and pursue excellence in every form of service.
- Living a life of repentance and reconciliation: The community resists evil, oppression, injustice, poverty, harm, and alienation, while standing with people who are poor, oppressed, hurting, or lonely and seeking just systems and structures.
These principles connect the congregation's welcome to its work in the world. Reconciliation is not limited to one activity or relationship; it is presented as a way of seeing people, sharing hospitality, pursuing spiritual maturity, serving with excellence, and pursuing justice.
Bad Girls, Mug Club and Monday Morning Study
Wesley organizes much of its shared life around recurring groups that meet in homes, online, at the church, and away from it. The schedule ranges from serious Bible study to conversation over coffee, lunch for seniors, and monthly social events.
- Monday Morning Study meets at 10:30 a.m. via Zoom for Bible study.
- Yoga meets Monday at 4:30 p.m. for one hour. The class costs $6, is taught by certified instructor Deb Konopka, and asks participants to bring a mat and wear comfortable clothes.
- Mug Club meets every Thursday at 9:00 a.m. at Sugar Grove Cafe. It is a social group for men centered on coffee and conversation.
- Bad Girls Book Study meets on the first and third Tuesdays of each month at 6:00 p.m., at various homes or via Zoom. The group reads Bible-study and topical books with a particular emphasis on issues relating to women, and all women are invited.
- Knitters and Knotters meet via Zoom for people interested in knitting and related crafts.
- Bell Choir practices under Thew Elliott, Wesley's Director of Liturgy & Music.
- Let's Go is a monthly social fellowship open to adult members and friends. Its gatherings are planned as social events around shared interests.
- Not Dead Yet is a group for seniors, although everyone is welcome. It meets for lunch on the fourth Friday of each month at noon.
- United Methodist Men build relationships through group activities organized around themes. United Women in Faith provides another avenue for women to participate in the life of the church.
Children and youth programs are also included among the ways to become involved. For adults, the emphasis on learning runs through Bible study, book groups, small groups, choirs, conversation, exercise, and shared meals rather than through a single program.
Visits, Prayer Shawls and Congregational Care
Wesley's care ministry includes lay visitors who regularly visit homebound congregants. They deliver seasonal altar flowers, poinsettias, and Christmas cookies made for the United Women in Faith's Cookie Walk. Cards are also sent for holidays and birthdays, as well as at other times when members of the congregation wish to remain in touch with one another. The cards are signed between and after Sunday services.
The Wesley Prayer and Friendship Shawl Ministry grew from an idea shared after two United Methodist Women attended a prayer-shawl gathering hosted by Sycamore United Methodist Church in 2008. That October, about eight women gathered to learn knitting and crochet. By November, the first shawls had been completed and blessed. The following April, the ministry took its present name. People who knit, crochet, perform other duties, and offer prayer support all share in this work.
The shawls are given with prayers of gratitude, joy, and inspiration, as well as prayers for physical, emotional, and spiritual healing. They are also given to support caregivers, accompany losses, and express love and care. Each shawl is blessed with a prayer that it will reach people in need of comfort, solace, healing, and peace.
Eyeglasses, Food Pantry Goods and Aurora Pride
Outreach begins with simple, ongoing collections inside the church. Eyeglasses can be placed in the Lions Club collection box in the narthex. Canned and boxed goods for a food pantry go in the cabinet in the lower west stairwell. Wesley also participates in the Aurora Pride Parade, making its presence part of the wider community rather than limiting service to the church's own rooms.
The men's fellowship includes service relationships such as work at Hesed House and involvement with Living Last Supper. Financial support can also be given through online giving. Givebutter tips are optional, and a person may enter zero if they do not wish to leave one. The church also offers an electronic automatic-withdrawal option for regular pledges.
Ordained Leadership and Shared Governance
Rev. Tammy Scott serves as senior pastor. She grew up in Lockport, where she was active in Sunday school and youth group at First UMC Lockport. She earned a Master of Divinity degree from Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary in 2006, was commissioned as a probationary deacon that year, ordained a full deacon in 2009, and was ordained an elder in The United Methodist Church on April 24, 2021. Before coming to Wesley, she served churches in Sugar Grove, Naperville, Minooka, Bolingbrook, Wilmette, and Joliet. Her ministry has included children, youth, families, administration, Bible studies, confirmation, preaching, and pastoral care.
Thew Elliott leads liturgy and music, Meredith Lindgren serves on the worship coordinator team, and Carol Stoffel coordinates congregational care. Their work supports the regular rhythm of worship, music, learning, and the relationships that extend into the community.
Wesley is governed by a nine-member Governing Board that acts in place of the Church Council. It supports and holds the pastor accountable while setting organizational direction, establishing policies, approving the annual budget, overseeing facility construction and repairs, addressing legal obligations, creating task forces when needed, and maintaining the congregation's records. This structure places responsibility for the church's direction and accountability in the hands of a representative body of the congregation.
Joining the Wesley Church Family
There are three ways to unite with Wesley: transfer of membership from another Methodist church, transfer from another denomination, or profession of faith. Baptism from another Christian denomination is recognized and affirmed in The United Methodist Church, so a person baptized elsewhere does not need to be baptized again. A person who has not been baptized may be baptized when joining or privately beforehand. New members are encouraged to take an orientation class to become acquainted with the church family.
Membership is open to everyone who professes belief in God through Jesus Christ. Wesley invites people to deepen their understanding of Christ, experience the grace of God, serve to make a difference, claim and share their gifts, belong to a community of faith, and broaden their friendships. Someone interested in joining can complete a Connection Card at any Sunday service and place it in the offering plate.
At 14 N. May St., Wesley United Methodist Church brings together a history rooted in Aurora's west side, a Reconciling identity, a disciplined life of discipleship, and a wide circle of worship, learning, care, fellowship, and service.