Need a website or online shop for your business? GetYourSite builds them from $24.99/month. Any small business · Half price for the first year, normally $49.99/month · Get 50% off

Sayville United Methodist Church: Two Centuries on the East Long Island Circuit

Methodist Church in Sayville, New York

Sayville United Methodist Church, established in 1833 as a stop on the East Long Island circuit, has met in a building raised along Jericho Turnpike on land donated by the Oakley family since 1845. The church pairs traditional and contemporary worship with Sunday school, youth and family ministries, music, counseling, and a wide network of community outreach across Suffolk County.

About United Methodist Church

Sayville United Methodist Church, at 164 Greene Avenue in the Suffolk County town of Sayville, is known for a Methodist presence on Long Island that reaches back to 1833, when the church was established as a stop on the East Long Island circuit. What began with meetings in local homes and class gatherings at a member's house became a building raised along Jericho Turnpike on property donated by the Oakley family, and the congregation that worships there today calls itself active, community-oriented, and made up of people at many ages and stages of faith.

A Stop on the East Long Island Circuit

The United Methodist Church of Sayville was established in 1833 as a stop on the East Long Island circuit. Methodist classes held regular meetings on the fourth Friday of each month at Jonas Newton's home in what is now Oakdale, and the church met in local homes until 1845, when the church along Jericho Tpke was erected on property donated by the Oakley family.

Suffolk County's Methodist roots reach back further still. Methodism in Winne-Comac began in 1783, when a society was formed after a sermon preached by John Phillips, a local Methodist preacher and tailor in the British Army during the War of Independence. By 1810, Comac had become part of the Suffolk County circuit along with Hauppauge and Sag Harbor, with preachers Henry Redstone and Coles Carpenter. There were no United Methodist churches in Comac until after 1918, when Brindley Field was brought into its own use during the First World War and became available for homes, stores, and the church.

The North Shore United Methodist Church, founded in 1970 with twenty founding members of the First United Methodist Church of Port Jefferson, New York, was born with a vision of a church located between Riverhead and Port Jefferson. Sayville's congregation belongs to that same sprawling story of circuits and class meetings, house worship, and purpose-built sanctuaries.

The congregation grew to 300 people in the 1960s, then decreased as parishioners moved away and other Protestant churches were established nearby. What has endured is the work of spiritual guidance and support that has marked the church for more than a century and a half, along with an identity the church describes as a healthy and diverse congregation of many ages and stages of faith.

The Bell, the Pink Windows, and a Belgian-Block Road

Sayville's building carries pieces of the one that came before it. Elements of the old church were used in the new structure, including the bell, the stained glass windows, the pink windows above the altar, the benches, and the lectern, so that the room still holds something of the generations who prayed in it before. In 1939 the building was painted, the landscape of the church grounds was improved, and a circular road was built with Belgian blocks and a border that continued along the sidewalk as a WPA project, a detail that still shapes the approach to the church. A parsonage built in 1896 stands to the left of the church on Middle Road.

Suffolk County's Methodist heritage is visible in meetinghouses like the one at 486 Townline Road in Commack, a two-story building with a large gable roof that still holds worship on the Sunday before July 4 and for Christmas Eve services, and that also serves the Long Island United Methodist Church of Korea. The cemetery around it holds graves dating back to the 18th century. Sayville's story belongs to that same long arc of a faith that built plain, durable rooms and kept using them.

Hymns and Organ, or a Band and a Praise Team

Methodist worship in Suffolk County comes in more than one key. Traditional services follow a structured format that incorporates liturgy, hymns, and organ music, offering a sense of familiarity and continuity with the historical traditions of the Methodist faith. Contemporary services take a more informal shape, often featuring contemporary Christian music accompanied by a band or praise team, a style that appeals to those seeking a more modern approach to worship connected to daily life. Either way, the services are alive with singing and prayer, and those who come are met with a welcoming atmosphere where all are accepted and encouraged to grow in their faith.

Music carries much of that atmosphere. Hymns in a traditional service create a sense of reverence and tradition, while contemporary songs encourage active participation and emotional engagement. Rituals such as baptism and communion serve as powerful symbols of a person's commitment to God and to grace, and they give worshipers a tangible way to express faith through action.

Sunday worship is also one part of a larger rhythm of prayer, Bible study, open dialogue, and fellowship that the church counts as the engine of spiritual growth. Through those practices, the congregation seeks to encourage and challenge one another toward deeper spiritual growth and a stronger faith in the power of Jesus Christ to transform the world.

Choirs, Cantatas, and Concerts That Reach the Community

For the county's Methodist congregations, music is more than an accompaniment to worship. It is an expression of spirituality, creativity, and shared joy. At Grace United Methodist Church in Valley Stream, the approach is typical of the tradition: hymns sung by the congregation create a unifying atmosphere in which everyone can take part, and the church choir adds depth and beauty with harmonies that uplift hearts and minds. For those who prefer more contemporary worship, modern praise music is part of the mix, reflecting an inclusive approach to spirituality.

The choirs and ensembles are varied. An adult choir leads many services, while children's and youth choirs introduce younger generations to the joy of singing. Handbell choirs and instrumental groups add further variety, and these groups do not stay inside the sanctuary. They perform at community events, carrying the church's message through music beyond its walls.

The musical calendar extends past weekly worship as well. Seasonal events such as Christmas cantatas, Easter performances, and summer concerts are highlights that draw members and visitors from the wider community, often through collaborations with local musicians that make room for a wide range of styles and talents. A BAFFA choir concert at Bayport Methodist Church has been staged as a celebration of the United States that also supports Habitat for Humanity, tying music to the housing work the church takes seriously.

Music education rounds it out. Through workshops, rehearsals, and mentorship, singers of all ages are encouraged to develop their skills and explore their musical gifts, reinforcing the idea that music is a lifelong journey of learning and expression.

Sunday School, Confirmation, and the Long Summer

Children are treated as a source of joy, wonder, and pride, and the programs built for them are designed to let them grow in the knowledge and traditions of the faith while living it out through service and fellowship. Sunday school classes are the foundation, giving children and young people the chance to study the faith's stories and to have fun and fellowship with their peers.

Vacation Bible School has long been a way for kids entering grades K-5 in September to learn about biblical stories, music, crafts, and recreational activities centered around a single topic. For older young people, confirmation is a class that lasts the entire school year and prepares them to make informed decisions about their religious lives, followed by the United Methodist Youth Scholarship. Older youth in the United Methodist Youth group organize and direct more ambitious fundraising activities such as car washes.

The wider menu of special ministries for children and young adults includes Sunday school classes, youth groups, mission trips, Bible studies, retreats, and summer camps. Seasonal events such as Christmas pageants and Easter egg hunts punctuate the year. Deacons serve as role models for young people in these settings, demonstrating how worship in the faith community is connected to service to God in the world.

When the Pastor Comes to You

Pastoral care in these congregations is deliberately unhurried. The pastor is available for counseling and makes visits to homes, hospitals, and nursing homes, and the invitation extends to people whether or not they are members of the congregation. Counseling is offered alongside the regular life of the church, and the church describes itself as a non-sectarian organization that provides spiritual guidance and religious services to its own congregation as well as several cultural and educational programs.

Support groups are offered for people dealing with addiction, mental health issues, and grief. Such groups provide a safe and welcoming environment in which to share stories and begin a healing journey, and the church's spiritual guidance and counseling services complement them. For families and couples, dedicated ministries provide resources for strengthening marriages, including guidance on traditional marriage vows and help with difficult conversations about faith. Methodists in New Directions offers congregations help with discernment, writing inclusive welcome statements, and understanding the Covenant of Conscience.

From the Church Door to the County Line

The church's outreach reaches well beyond its own membership. It works with local organizations to provide food pantries for people who are struggling financially, and it offers support groups for those dealing with addiction or mental health issues. When homelessness is imminent, a social ministry in the county can help with rent payments, mortgage costs, or a security deposit for a new home.

Much of this work is ecumenical. The Long Island Council of Churches, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that coordinates the ecumenical work of churches in Nassau and Suffolk counties, supports people in need with emergency housing, food, transportation to doctors' offices, public services, assistance with prescriptions, clothing, and blankets. The LICC box sits in the parking lot behind the First Presbyterian Church of Levittown at 474 Wantagh Avenue in Levittown, New York.

Other partners extend the reach further. Anchor House is a Christ-centered drug-free treatment center in Brooklyn that provides professional and vocational training so people can overcome addiction and lead productive lives. Bayport United Methodist Church supports Habitat for Humanity and has taken part in the construction of a house in North Bellport. Donations of furniture, home supplies, vintage items, and clothing are gathered at Bay Shore United Methodist Church at 350 Main Street in Islip. The Suffolk County Department of Social Services is a source of information about transportation programs, government services, and programs for the elderly, while BIAS Help, reached at 877-End-Bias (363-242), offers support and advice to victims of discrimination, hate crimes, harassment, and cyberbullying. EAC Network, a social services agency that works to empower, help, and care for people in need on Long Island and New York City, points people toward programs that improve quality of life.

Faith without service is not the picture the church paints. As a connectional church, it contributes to mission programs and relief efforts both locally and globally through the work of the New York Annual Conference and its partners, including the General Board of Global Ministries and United Methodist Women. That work extends to places where there are floods, hurricanes, wars, and famines.

Volunteering, Boards, and the Ministry of Lay Servants

There is no shortage of ways to lend a hand. Volunteers can serve as ushers and greeters, greeting visitors, helping with events, and assisting during services, and churches across the county are always glad to have people who will do the unglamorous work of hospitality. Food pantries, mentoring at-risk youth, park cleanups, and community drives are all listed as places where time is welcome. Church staff serve as the first point of contact for people who want to get involved, and they can point volunteers toward benefits and resources through the Suffolk County Department of Social Services.

Leadership development has its own structure. The Ministry of Lay Servants is a United Methodist system for lay leadership development, and its courses are designed to help members build the skills they need to serve as lay leaders in their local churches. Research cited by the church points to a striking finding: older adults who hold lay leadership positions in religious groups experience slower average rates of functional decline than those who do not attend church regularly, or those who attend regularly without leading. Serving, in other words, appears to be its own kind of medicine.

Serving on committees and boards is another route in, and the county's United Methodist churches draw on the expertise of people from many walks of life, from communications and public policy to law and finance. For students, the Alumni Sponsored Internship Program scholarship offers a way to explore areas of potential professional interest, participate in projects that address important societal problems, and create positive change in the local community. Placements can put a student alongside hospital chaplaincy teams that include chaplains, rabbis, priests, and imams, available to advise people of all faiths as well as people who do not have a spiritual practice.

What This Church Believes

The people of the United Methodist Church are devoted to living out their faith by making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world. The Social Principles of the church, described in the Book of Discipline, are divided into six parts that explain how United Methodist Christians are called to live in God's world. The General Conference is the only body with authority to speak on behalf of the entire church, and disputes over the interpretation of church law contained in the Discipline are sent to the Judicial Council. The United Methodist Church is the legal successor to the Protestant Methodist Church, one of the earlier parts of today's church.

For years, the denomination has been embroiled in a deep internal conflict over the acceptance of homosexual clergy and same-sex marriage, a conflict that has split some congregations away and left others working through what some call a divorce. Some Long Island congregations have approved new inclusive welcome statements, hung inclusive messages, and raised rainbow flags, while others have completed disaffiliation and still others have chosen to remain. Thomas Goodhue, a retired United Methodist minister and former director of the Long Island Council of Churches, expected most congregations on Long Island to stay with the main denomination, which supports homosexual clergy and same-sex marriage and will continue to be known as the United Methodist Church.

The church's own welcome is stated without hedging. Its mission is to share God's love by creating safe places where everyone is accepted and welcome, and connecting people's needs to God's presence. The congregation seeks to be in ministry with all of God's people, regardless of gender, race, age, class, ethnicity, culture, country of origin, ability and disability, or sexual orientation. The churches of the connection describe themselves in similar language: Hamden Plains United Methodist Church is a diverse community united in Christ and a pleasant place to worship, serve, and grow in faith, and UMC of Babylon is a connectional church that contributes to mission programs and relief efforts both locally and globally while ministering to four communities, each one different.

An Active Congregation, Rooted and Still Growing

Sayville United Methodist Church has been an active, community-oriented church with a healthy and diverse congregation of many ages and stages of faith since 1833, and the shape of its life has changed with the times: from class meetings held on the fourth Friday of each month in a house in what is now Oakdale, to a sanctuary raised on Oakley land along Jericho Tpke, to a congregation that now speaks of baptism and communion alongside Bible study classes, fellowship opportunities, prayer meetings, and counseling sessions with its pastor. Its work reaches outward through food pantries, housing help, support groups, volunteer projects, mission and relief efforts at home and abroad, and the ecumenical partnerships of the Long Island Council of Churches. The message holding those pieces together is a simple one, stated in the church's own terms: God loves and accepts all people, and the church is a living church that tries to show it.

Frequently asked questions

Does the church offer counseling?

Yes. The pastor provides counseling and makes visits to homes, hospitals, and nursing homes, and people who are not members of the congregation are welcome to ask for that care.

What is Sunday worship like?

Worship centers on singing and prayer. Traditional services use liturgy, hymns, and organ music, while contemporary services use contemporary Christian music with a band or praise team. Baptism and communion are part of the church's life.

What ministries are there for children and youth?

Sunday school classes, a confirmation class that lasts an entire school year, youth groups, mission trips, Bible studies, retreats, summer camps, and Vacation Bible School for children entering grades K-5, along with seasonal events such as Christmas pageants and Easter egg hunts.

How does the church help people who are struggling financially?

It works with local organizations to provide food pantries, and a social ministry can help with rent payments, mortgage costs, and security deposits when homelessness is imminent. Partner congregations and the Long Island Council of Churches also provide emergency housing, food, transportation to doctors' offices, help with prescriptions, clothing, and blankets.

Is help available for addiction, mental health, and grief?

Yes. The church offers support groups and counseling for people dealing with addiction, mental health issues, and grief, along with spiritual guidance and a safe, welcoming place to begin the healing process.

Is the church open to people of different backgrounds and beliefs?

Yes. The congregation seeks to be in ministry with all of God's people regardless of gender, race, age, class, ethnicity, culture, country of origin, ability and disability, or sexual orientation, and it describes itself as non-sectarian in providing spiritual guidance and religious services.

How can people serve in the church?

Volunteer roles include greeting visitors, assisting during services, helping with events, and serving on committees and boards. The Ministry of Lay Servants offers courses for people who want to serve as lay leaders, and the Alumni Sponsored Internship Program places students in ministry and community projects.

Explore more churches

Looking somewhere else? Find churches near any ZIP code, city or address:

Plan your visit

Location on Map

Loading map…

Location Information

  • Address 164 Greene Ave, Sayville, NY 11782
  • County Suffolk County
  • Area code 631
  • Time zone EST (observes DST)
  • PMSA 5380
  • FIPS 36103