Need a website or online shop for your business? GetYourSite builds them from $24.99/month. Any small business · Half price for the first year, normally $49.99/month · Get 50% off

St. John's Evangelical Lutheran Church: A Village Congregation in Lancaster, NY Since 1844

Lutheran Church in Lancaster, New York

St. John's Evangelical Lutheran Church is an ELCA congregation in the Village of Lancaster, New York, founded in 1844 and centered on its 1877 sanctuary on Pleasant Avenue. It offers Saturday evening and Sunday morning worship, Sunday School, a livestream on YouTube, and ministry groups ranging from WELCA and LYMA to a youth group, quilters and a prayer shawl ministry.

About St John's Lutheran Church

St. John's Evangelical Lutheran Church sits in the heart of the Village of Lancaster, an outer-ring suburb of Buffalo, New York. Founded in 1844 by German farming families who had settled in the area after the opening of the Erie Canal, the congregation has been gathering for worship on Pleasant Avenue for more than 180 years. Today St. John's is a member congregation of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), a denomination of nearly 10,000 Lutheran communities across the country.

Open, Inviting, Alive in Christ

Those three phrases are St. John's way of describing itself, and Pastor Jamie Retallack takes them seriously. A pastor since 2011 and the called pastor of St. John's since midway through 2019, Jamie explains the meaning this way: Jesus met criminals, outcasts, widows, the sick and others on the margins, so the church chooses to be open to all. Worship should never make anyone feel out of place, so the congregation works to make people feel invited. And the church is called to do God's work in the world, so St. John's aims to be alive in Christ through worship, fellowship, and service.

The same theme runs through the mission statement: St. John's provides an inviting environment for spreading God's Word through worship, teaching and fellowship to address the spiritual needs of the congregation and community. A short verse from Ezekiel 18:32 anchors the welcome. Turn, then, and live.

From the Village's First German Church to St. John's

St. John's story begins in 1844 as the First German Lutheran Church of Lancaster, formed when area Lutherans and Reformed Protestants agreed to share a building. After more than twenty years of friction, the Reformed community rolled the structure away on logs one night. The Lutherans took the matter to court, won a financial settlement, and used it to build again. In 1877 the present sanctuary was completed, with seating for 500, and the congregation has worshipped there ever since.

By 1917, when the congregation joined the United Lutheran Church in America, the community adopted the name it still carries. The 1950s brought a fresh education wing, an expanded chancel with a pipe organ, and two new parsonages to house the pastoral staff. The chancel organ installed in that era is still at the heart of Sunday worship.

Worship on Saturdays, Sundays, and Online

St. John's keeps a rhythm that fits both the working week and family life. On Saturdays at 5:30 p.m., an in-person service gathers worshippers who prefer a quieter, evening setting. On Sundays at 10:00 a.m., the congregation meets in person and online together, with the service livestreamed through the church's YouTube channel and recent services available on demand there.

Children have their own place in the Sunday hour. Sunday School meets at 10:00 a.m. from September through June, running alongside worship so families can attend together. A confirmation curriculum walks older students through the Lutheran faith in age-appropriate stages.

The church office at 55 Pleasant Avenue is open Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday from 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. Visitors and members can also reach the office by phone at 716-683-8972 or by email at stjohnslancaster55@gmail.com.

Music in the Chancel

Music carries a long tradition at St. John's. An adult choir and a hand bell choir invite singers of all experience levels to join in, and the chancel pipe organ anchors the music each Sunday. Dr. Vicky Chang, a pipe organ composer originally from Taiwan whose journey to Western New York was profiled by WBFO, is one of the regular organists, and the chancel organ itself dates to the 1950s expansion that gave the sanctuary much of its present form.

Ministry Groups for Every Age

  • Women of the ELCA (WELCA) provides women of the congregation and community a place to support one another.
  • Lutheran Young Men's Association (LYMA) brings the men of St. John's together for fellowship.
  • Youth Group offers middle and high school students a safe, fun place to belong.
  • Sunday School and Confirmation walks children of all ages through the Lutheran faith.
  • Quilters piece quilts by hand year-round to send to Lutheran World Relief.
  • Prayer Shawl Ministry knits and crochets prayer shawls and baptismal baby blankets for those in need of comfort.
  • Book Club gives members a relaxed way to get to know one another and wrestle with ideas together.

Wrapping the World in Quilts and Yarn

Two of St. John's longest-running hands-on ministries are quilts and yarn. The Quilters work for months at a time on each piece, building a steady supply of beautiful quilts for Lutheran World Relief, which distributes them to people in crisis around the world. The Prayer Shawl Ministry pairs the same careful handwork with prayer: each shawl is knitted or crocheted with a specific person in mind and given to someone who needs comfort, while baptismal baby blankets are made for the youngest members of the congregation.

Connected to Lancaster

St. John's is woven into the life of the surrounding community. Members participate in the Lancaster Garden Club, and the building hosts the regular meetings of a local Girl Scout troop, the Queen City Chordsmen barbershop chorus, and a Narcotics Anonymous group. The congregation also supports Guiding Eyes for the Blind, a nonprofit that provides guide dogs to people with vision loss.

Members keep in touch through The Good News, a monthly newsletter offered in PDF and animated online editions going back to 2023, and through weekly bulletins posted after each service. Giving can be done by mail to the church office or online through PayPal or credit card.

A Place in the Village

More than 180 years after the first German Lutheran families built their shared house of worship, St. John's still gathers on Pleasant Avenue in the center of Lancaster. Whether you come on a Saturday evening or a Sunday morning, in person or through the livestream, the welcome is the same. Open to all, eager to invite, and alive in Christ.

Frequently asked questions

When are worship services held?

Saturday evening at 5:30 p.m. (in person) and Sunday morning at 10:00 a.m. (in person and online). Sunday School for children also meets at 10:00 a.m. from September through June.

Can I watch services online?

Yes. Sunday morning services are livestreamed on the church's YouTube channel, where recent services are also kept on demand.

What denomination is St. John's?

St. John's is a congregation of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA).

Where is the church located?

55 Pleasant Avenue, Lancaster, NY 14086, in the heart of the Village of Lancaster.

When is the church office open?

Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday from 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. The office phone is 716-683-8972 and the email is stjohnslancaster55@gmail.com.

How can I give?

Weekly offerings can be mailed to the church office or given online through PayPal or credit card.

Who is the pastor?

Pastor Jamie Retallack, who has served St. John's since midway through 2019.

What ministries can I get involved in?

St. John's offers WELCA for women, LYMA for men, a youth group, Sunday School and confirmation, a choir and hand bell choir, a quilters group sending quilts to Lutheran World Relief, a prayer shawl ministry, and a book club.

Explore more churches

Looking somewhere else? Find churches near any ZIP code, city or address:

Plan your visit

Location on Map

Loading map…

Location Information

  • Address 55 Pleasant Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086
  • County Erie County
  • Area code 716
  • Time zone EST (observes DST)
  • Metro area (MSA) 1280
  • FIPS 36029