Need a website or online shop for your business? GetYourSite builds them from $24.99/month. Any small business · Half price for the first year, normally $49.99/month · Get 50% off

St. John UCC in Cumberland: From 1841 Home Gatherings to a Fourth Church

Presbyterian/Reformed Church in Indianapolis, Indiana

St. John United Church of Christ - Cumberland is an Open and Affirming congregation at 11910 E. Prospect St., with roots in German immigrant worship dating to 1841 and a fourth church building in use since 2021. Sunday worship is at 10 a.m. in person and online, with Sunday school, music, conversation groups, a free third-Thursday community meal, and mission giving.

About St John United Church-Christ

St. John United Church of Christ - Cumberland is located at 11910 E. Prospect St. in Indianapolis, in the Cumberland area. It is known for an Open and Affirming welcome, Sunday worship at 10 a.m. in person and online, and a ministry life that includes Sunday school, sacred music, conversation groups, a free monthly meal and mission giving. Its story reaches back to 1841, yet the congregation now gathers in its fourth church building.

Four Church Buildings, One Cumberland Congregation

St. John's story begins in 1841, when German settlers in Cumberland gathered for worship in their homes. Heinrich Koch donated land for a church building and school. A small frame building on the National Road, also identified as U.S. 40, became the landmark for which German Church Road was named. In November 1855, fifteen members signed the congregation's constitution, and in 1856 it became a member of the Evangelical Synod of North America.

Attendance outgrew that first building by 1864. The Civil War made construction prohibitively expensive, so the second church was not raised until 1866. Its tower bell was imported from Germany in 1872. All services were in German until 1912, when members approved one English service each month. On January 1, 1913, they voted to build again. The third church opened in 1914 and served the congregation for more than a century.

The church's name changed as its affiliations changed. The Evangelical Church merged with the Reformed Church in 1934, creating St. John Evangelical and Reformed Church. A state-of-the-art pipe Kilgan organ was dedicated in 1936, and the sanctuary was updated in 1954. A union with the Congregational Church in 1957 brought the name St. John United Church of Christ, while a Sunday School wing was added in 1958.

By the early 21st century, the century-old building no longer served the congregation's needs. Harry Muesing's will donated land at Prospect Street and Carroll Road, also known as County Line Road, for a new church. Stained glass windows from the old sanctuary moved to the new building, and the Kilgan organ was totally refurbished in 2008-2009. The fourth church welcomed its first in-person service on March 7, 2021. The congregation's hope is that this building will serve Cumberland and the surrounding area for another 100 years.

Sunday Worship at Ten, Learning at Nine

Sunday worship begins at 10:00 a.m. at 11910 E. Prospect St. and is also available online. St. John livestreams on Facebook, where viewers can join live chat during worship, and on YouTube. The church office is open Tuesday through Thursday from 8:30 a.m. to noon, and the main phone number is (317) 894-7958.

At 9:00 a.m., Sunday School is offered both in person and online for children of all ages. Pathfinders, a class for discussing UCC readings and devotions, also meets in person at 9:00. A worship gathering centers on scripture readings and hymns; the adult choir sings most Sundays from September through May. The restored Kilgan pipe organ and stained glass carried from the previous church give the sanctuary a visual and musical link to earlier generations. Sermons can be watched live and in an archive reaching back to January 2025.

Open and Affirming in Word and Practice

St. John is a come-as-you-are church for believers and nonbelievers alike who are looking for connection. St. John believes that God made each person and fully loves each one just as they are, and it welcomes everyone to participate in worship, community, membership and leadership regardless of sex, gender expression or identity, race, marital status or orientation. It is a designated United Church of Christ Open and Affirming congregation.

Its purpose is to love God with all heart, soul, mind and strength and to love neighbors as themselves, as set out in Mark 12:29-31. Its mission is to do justice, love kindness and walk humbly with God, from Micah 6:8. Those commitments are joined by a promise to be a caring, serving and adapting church that remains open and accepting of all people.

Children Explore Jesus at Sunday School

The Youth Sunday School has a safe, accepting and magical space where children of all ages can share thoughts and feelings on topics surrounding Jesus. A range of open-ended materials lets children communicate in any of five stages of language, allowing each child to express an idea in the way that feels comfortable. The class values each person's point of view as it explores its subjects.

An Adult Choir, Chimes, and a Restored Organ

St. John has an adult choir and a chime choir that add to the worship experience. The adult choir sings most Sundays from September through May and rehearses Thursday afternoons from 3:30 to 4:30 p.m. The chimes play around six times a year and join the adult choir when a piece of music requires it. They rehearse Sunday mornings from 9:00 to 9:30, usually three to four weeks before playing.

Faith in Conversation at the Table

Holy Spirits meets about every six weeks to gather and share in conversation and community. The group turns an ordinary meal into a sacred space through table fellowship, exploring faith, ethics, morality and life over dinner and drinks at different restaurants and breweries around Indianapolis. It is open to anyone over 21 years old. For those on a journey of recovery from alcohol, gatherings are held at locations that sell and serve alcohol, and members of the group often order an alcoholic drink.

A Free Hot Meal on the Third Thursday

The community meal has been part of church life every month since 2007. On the third Thursday of each month, a free hot meal and friendship are offered from 5:00 to 6:30 p.m. in the Fellowship Hall. Everyone is welcome, and the meal reflects St. John's commitment to caring for the needs of people in the community.

Community Care, led through benevolence and elders, is grounded in goodwill, kindness and charitableness. Benevolence encompasses compassion, generosity and a sincere desire to do good to all people. St. John's care reaches local, national and international concerns and needs, expressing a commitment to share and care for one another. Deacons keep the fellowship, hospitality and worship spaces ready for fun, fellowship, worship and community gatherings.

Cardio Drumming for Community Health

Cardio Drumming meets Wednesday evenings at 6:00 p.m. in the MAC building next to the church. A qualified instructor leads the $5 session, and all are welcome. Participants need only a large exercise ball, a tub to place it on, drumsticks and a willingness to move. The group drums to many kinds of songs, including requested selections and music tied to the season.

Giving That Feeds Local Ministry and Wider Mission

Gifts of time, talent and treasure support community meals, community care and worship ministries. Donations can be made with cash or a check during Sunday worship, mailed by USPS, sent as stock or as required minimum distributions, or arranged as a recurring donation through PayPal online. The aim is an open-hospitality church that feeds people's bodies, minds and spirits and works toward a more just world.

Our Church's Wider Mission Basic support allows local contributions to move through associations and conferences to United Church of Christ national offices in Cleveland, helping provide care, services and support for affiliated partners. Strengthen the Church supports youth ministries and full-time leaders for new churches in parts of the country where the UCC does not have a strong presence, and it also supports new initiatives in existing churches.

One Great Hour of Sharing supports international work involving clean water, food, education, health care, small-business microcredit, advocacy, refugee and displaced-person resettlement, and emergency relief and rehabilitation. Neighbors in Need supports justice and compassion ministries, including the Council for American Indian Ministries, justice and advocacy, and direct service projects supported by Justice and Local Church Ministries. The Christmas Fund offers direct financial support to active and retired clergy, lay employees and surviving spouses, including emergency grants and supplemental health and annuity assistance.

Leadership Built on Long Service

Senior Pastor John Gantt was ordained in 1960 as the United Church of Christ was being formed, during a period of national civil rights protests. He participated in the March on Washington and other demonstrations, served on human rights committees and has 65 years of active ministry. He has been senior pastor of three congregations with at least 1,000 members and has also served rural and smaller churches. For 18 years he was executive director of Crossroad, formerly Ft. Wayne Children's Home, a residential treatment center for emotionally troubled and abused children and youth. His work also included Back Bay Mission in Biloxi, Mississippi, and disaster repair camps in Kentucky and West Virginia; St. John members volunteered with him in some of those experiences.

Gantt has served as interim conference minister on three occasions, with assignments in the Central Pacific, Indiana-Kentucky and Heartland conferences. He completed a clinical training year as student associate pastor at Chicago's Kenwood Ellis Community Center and Church, a multi-racial congregation led by a Nisei senior pastor. He and his wife were two of only three members in that church who were not persons of color. He has also assisted congregations in developing Open and Affirming covenants, including St. John's, and Just Peace covenants.

Choir and Chimes Director Jim Kiser graduated from the Jacobs School of Music at Indiana University. Before joining St. John, he directed adult and bell choirs at Medina United Church of Christ - Congregational for 15 years and helped start a youth bell choir. Pianist and Organist Suellen Kipp has taught choral music in public schools for more than 25 years and holds degrees from Ball State University and Indiana University.

St. John's Consistory is the church's executive body. It meets monthly to discuss missions and ministries and conduct the church's overall business. Elders provide spiritual leadership and make recommendations about special services, programs and the spiritual life of the congregation, while deacons ensure that the church's gathering spaces remain ready to welcome the surrounding community.

From the 1841 home gatherings to the 2021 opening of its fourth sanctuary, St. John remains centered on worship, open hospitality, learning, shared food and service. Its present home at 11910 E. Prospect St. carries that work forward for Cumberland and the surrounding Indianapolis area.

Frequently asked questions

When is Sunday worship?

Worship is held every Sunday at 10:00 a.m. both in person and online. St. John also livestreams on Facebook and YouTube.

Where does St. John meet?

St. John is at 11910 E. Prospect St., Indianapolis, IN 46239.

What time is Sunday School?

Sunday School is offered at 9:00 a.m. online and in person for children of all ages. Pathfinders also meets in person at 9:00 a.m.

Is St. John an Open and Affirming congregation?

Yes. St. John is a designated United Church of Christ Open and Affirming congregation, and everyone is welcome to participate in worship, community, membership and leadership regardless of sex, gender expression or identity, race, marital status or orientation.

When is the community meal?

A free hot meal is served on the third Thursday of each month from 5:00 to 6:30 p.m. in the Fellowship Hall. It is open to everyone.

What are the church office hours?

The church office is open Tuesdays through Thursdays from 8:30 a.m. to noon.

Can I make a donation online?

Recurring online donations can be made through PayPal. Cash and check gifts are accepted during Sunday worship, and checks, stock and required minimum distributions can be mailed to the church.

Explore more churches

Looking somewhere else? Find churches near any ZIP code, city or address:

Plan your visit

Location on Map

Loading map…

Location Information

  • Address 11000 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229
  • County Marion County
  • Area code 317
  • Time zone EST (no DST)
  • Metro area (MSA) 3480
  • FIPS 18097