St. Andrews Presbyterian Church stands at 705 Michigan Boulevard in North Dunedin, Florida, a west central Florida coastal church that has called the same Michigan Boulevard address home since its first members met in 1958. It is known for two very different Sunday worship gatherings under one roof: a contemporary service with drums, guitars and lights at 9:30 a.m., and a traditional service with pipe organ, choir and robes at 11:00 a.m. The same sermon is preached at both, and the church's central refrain, “Love God | Love People | Push Back Darkness,” runs through its mission, its music and its student ministries.
One Morning, Two Ways to Worship
St. Andrews describes its Sunday lineup plainly: contemporary worship with drums, lights and guitars at 9:30 a.m., then traditional worship with a pipe organ, choir and robes at 11:00 a.m. The traditional service is built around one of the finest pipe organs in the area, and the contemporary gathering is led by worship leader Brian Caudill, a local Tampa Bay musician who has worked full-time across the Tampa Bay area since 1996.
Both services last about an hour. Words to songs and hymns are projected onto screens so people can sing along or engage as they are comfortable, and a pastor shares the same hope-filled message about Jesus at each service. Coffee, lemonade and light snacks are available before and after the 9:30 gathering, which makes it an easy time to arrive early.
The atmosphere is deliberately easygoing. St. Andrews says Sundays are exciting and relaxed, that people will not be met with shame, guilt or condemnation, and that it does not care how you are dressed or what candidate you voted for. The church describes itself as made up of imperfect people with every kind of story. People who are new to St. Andrews can fill out a short form and receive a free welcome gift, and a first-visit plan lets a family share what to expect in advance so the church can prepare a warm arrival.
From an Orange Juice Plant to Michigan Boulevard
St. Andrews began in March 1958, started by another church, First Presbyterian Church of Dunedin. Late in 1957, Dr. Thomas P. Johnston, pastor of First Presbyterian, had a vision to start a new church. A survey of the area and rapid population growth in the county made North Dunedin the logical direction in which to move, and the first gathering took place in what was at the time the HP Hood orange juice plant, now the Coca-Cola plant in Dunedin. A band of determined people met there until the church had land, an architect and a new building on Michigan Boulevard.
The church remembers its history as one of welcome and courage. The men and women who helped shape St. Andrews are described as genuinely welcoming to everyone, including open opposition to Ku Klux Klan activity in the area “back in the day.” That spirit is summed up as forward-thinking, risk-taking, hands-on and mission-minded.
St. Andrews is a member church of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), one of the Reformed theological traditions of the Christian church, and an active member of Fellowship Community, a network of churches and leaders called together to proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ by growing in Christ's likeness, living by God's Word and joining in God's mission in the world. In the summer of 2016, Westminster Presbyterian Church of New Port Richey merged with St. Andrews, and the memorial garden of that church now lives in Dunedin beside St. Andrews' own memorial space.
Love God, Love People, Push Back Darkness
“Making a difference in the community” is the mission behind the three-part refrain the church repeats everywhere: LOVE GOD, LOVE PEOPLE, PUSH BACK DARKNESS. The church frames that mission with John 3:16: “For this is how God loved the world: He gave his one and only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish but have eternal life.”
The core values name a Jesus-shaped identity, biblical integrity, thoughtful theology, accountable community, egalitarian ministry, a mission center, spiritual focus, leadership growth and kingdom vitality. Alongside them, the church names what matters to it in practical terms: warm friendships; growing in faith through studying God's Word together; challenging, biblical and practical preaching; funding and supporting ministry to youth and families; compassionate caregiving that gives hope and friendship instead of condemnation; a variety of worship styles; music made for God; ministry in which every generation finds meaning and purpose; and being down-to-earth, real people who like to laugh.
Looking ahead, the church describes itself as committed to fostering a family built around hope, with inclusion and belonging at the center of who it is as followers of Christ. Wherever a person is in the faith journey, St. Andrews says that person is welcome.
What St. Andrews Believes
Jesus Christ is at the center of everything at St. Andrews. The church confesses that Jesus, the eternal Son of God, “uniquely entered human history and became a real human being, fully human and fully God,” and that he is the only one who can reconcile people to God. He lived a sinless and exemplary life, died on the cross in our place and rose again to prove his victory and empower us for life, and he is coming back again as he promised.
The Trinity is affirmed as one sovereign, eternal God, Creator of all things, existing eternally in three Persons: God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit, totally loving and completely holy. The Bible is held to be God's uniquely revealed and written Word, inspired by the Holy Spirit and the church's first and final authority in all areas of faith and life, accurate, authoritative and applicable to everyday life.
On sin and reconciliation, the church teaches that sin has separated each person from God and from his purpose for life, that the image of God in human beings is now broken and distorted, and that forgiveness and a fresh start come through repentance, belief in Jesus and commitment to his will. The Church is affirmed as necessary for believers to meet regularly to worship God and enjoy his presence and work in the community of believers.
Two sacraments are recognized, Baptism and the Lord's Supper. Through the sacraments, God seals believers in redemption, renews their identity as his people and marks them for service. St. Andrews' own teaching calls the church Reformed, embracing its Protestant theological heritage.
Overflow: Babies Through High Schoolers
The student ministries carry the name Overflow, with a vision of helping each child know God fully, see themselves the way God sees them and love others the way God loves them, so that they can take Jesus into home, school and neighborhood. The goal is safe, age-appropriate environments where children learn about Jesus in creative and relevant ways.
- Nursery, infants through Pre-K. Nursery care with trained staff and volunteers is available from 9:20 a.m. Parents bring infants and toddlers to the sanctuary with necessary items such as diapers and bottles before the first service. Once a child is in Pre-K and potty trained, the family moves up to the primary group.
- Primary group, Pre-K through 5th grade. Children and their parents or guardians come to the sanctuary at 9:30 a.m. for live music and a short children's message with the congregation. Afterward they head to the sanctuary lobby for snacks, games and a lesson from the monthly curriculum, where parents pick them up. On Wednesdays from 6:00 to 7:00 p.m., the same group meets in the sanctuary for snacks, crafts, games and a short lesson.
- Youth group, 6th through 12th grades. Students are encouraged to stay for the 9:30 a.m. worship service and to use their spiritual gifts by serving in the nursery or primary group, participating in the music worship team, helping in the tech booth or wherever else they are called.
Children's safety is a priority, and first-time families go through a detailed check-in process for St. Andrews Kids, so visitors are asked to allow an extra ten minutes for sign-in. If staff need to reach a parent during a service, they send a text, and parents are asked to leave the worship center immediately to find the staff member or volunteer waiting with their child.
Life Groups for Growth, Care and Service
Life Groups are the church's small-group network, organized around four needs: spiritual growth, a social space for Christian friendships, mutual care, and meaningful ministry. Groups care for their members, support the congregation's mission and reach out to people beyond the group.
- Sunday, 9:30 a.m.: Davidson Group studies the Gospel of Luke. A Bible is all that is needed, and one can be loaned if you forget yours.
- Sunday, 6:30 p.m.: Impact meets by Zoom on the second and fourth Sundays.
- Monday, 6:00 p.m.: Life Out Loud meets in Room 12.
- Monday, 7:00 p.m.: Love Does meets in a hybrid format, on Zoom and in a home.
- Tuesday, 2:00 p.m.: Presbyterian Women Circles and a Bible study on the Book of Revelation meet by Zoom on the second Tuesday of each month.
- Wednesday, 6:00 to 7:20 p.m.: A Deeper Life, with the invitation to dive deeper, live fuller and find purpose.
- Friday, 6:30 p.m.: Friday Night Light meets by Zoom on the first and third Fridays, working through RightNow Media videos.
RightNow Media, a free video-based, on-demand Bible study library with more than 14,000 studies, is available to people connected with St. Andrews and can be watched on a smartphone, tablet, computer or TV, alone, with children or as a group. Bible reading plans and the Bible app support daily reading and study for those who want to dig into Scripture between gatherings.
Mission Work in Dunedin and Around the World
St. Andrews describes its local mission as loving God, loving people and pushing back darkness, carried out through partnerships with local organizations and through its own projects. Church members serve with Angel Tree, the Dunedin Cares Food Pantry, Homeless Empowerment Project, Habitat for Humanity, Kimberly Home Pregnancy Resource Center in Clearwater, local VA hospitals, the Peace Memorial Cold Night Shelter, projects that support local elementary schools, Rake and Roll yard clean-ups, RCS and the Sheriff's Youth Ranch.
Globally, the church responds by sending short-term mission teams and by supporting a missionary who is reaching unreached people. Named work includes For Haiti with Love, Heifer International, a Honduras mission trip with HOI, an Overflow Student Ministries summer mission trip and a Zona Maya mission trip.
Presbyterian Women, an organization made up of women of the church, supports many of these local and global projects with its own funds and resources. Anyone with an interest, talent or availability is invited to serve somewhere in the church, an idea the teaching elders describe as “getting in the boat.”
Prayer, Care and Ways to Give
A prayer chain keeps a list of people who agree to pray for those in need, seeking comfort, guidance, healing, restoration, or expressing sorrow, joy and gratitude. Requests are kept confidential and shared only with the prayer team for the purposes of prayer. The caring ministry offers visits at home, in the hospital or in a nursing or retirement home, along with a trained, confidential listener for people dealing with divorce, illness, job problems, or the simple need for someone to listen without judging or fixing. A friendly voice answers the church's line at 727-734-5493.
Giving is described in practical terms. Everything belongs to God, and the church gives to love the city and bring hope to lives. Offerings can be placed in the giving plate each week. Checks made payable to St. Andrews Presbyterian Church can be mailed to 705 Michigan Boulevard or dropped in the mailbox slot next to the church office door, and automatic recurring gifts can be arranged through a bank. Secure one-time or recurring gifts can also be made through Breeze, the church's management system, and a hurricane relief fund is supported as well.
For those ready to take a further step, the church lays out a path: reading the Bible, responding to God's call for salvation, baptism, communion, membership and service. Membership classes prepare new members who take part in worship, love and service in the community.
Baptism, Communion and the Memorial Gardens
Baptism is treated as a sacred act of the congregation's worship rather than a private ceremony, and even beach baptisms continue the Sunday service with the congregation present. The church recognizes two sacraments, established by God and commended by Christ: Baptism and the Lord's Supper. Through the sacraments, God seals believers in redemption, renews their identity as his people and marks them for service. Baptism is open to those who profess faith and to the children of believers, with at least one believing parent, and may be done by sprinkling, pouring or immersion. The church does not teach that baptism itself brings salvation, recognizes baptisms performed in other Christian churches and does not rebaptize. Sponsors, the church's term for godparents, commit to pray for a child over the years and to share in the family's spiritual life.
The Lord's Supper is served the first Sunday of the month, and Communion is also celebrated on Maundy Thursday and Christ the King Sunday. The pastor takes bread and grape juice, gives thanks, breaks the bread, pours the juice and shares them with the people, who eat and drink. The invitation extends to all who have been baptized, regardless of denominational affiliation, and baptized children being nurtured in the Christian faith are included. St. Andrews stresses that access to the table is not a right conferred on the worthy but a privilege given to those who come in faith, repentance and love. The “wine” served is non-alcoholic grape juice.
On the church grounds, the St. Andrews Kirk Memorial Gardens are being re-landscaped under a plan approved by the Session, with the Celtic cross remaining the focal point. In front of the cross is a garden with pavers and granite memorial stones where the names of deceased members are etched, and the paved area takes the shape of a ship in memory of Kirk Hall. Space is set aside for temporary seating for informal memorial services. Just east of that garden, the Westminster Memorial Garden holds a paver base and a granite stone for members of Westminster Presbyterian Church of New Port Richey, whose church merged with St. Andrews in 2016 and whose memorial space moved to Dunedin. The remaining land is planned as a peaceful meditation garden with walking paths, benches, smaller gardens and an area near the patio room for small group meetings and family picnics. Names can be etched into the granite stones, and families may donate benches, etched pavers or upright granite features carrying Bible verses. Both memorial gardens are located at 705 Michigan Boulevard in Dunedin.
The People Behind the Pulpit and the Music
St. Andrews is led by the Rev. Dr. David Hunsicker, pastor. Ron Marston serves as a commissioned lay pastor alongside his work as the church's office and facilities manager. Brian Caudill leads contemporary worship, and Mark Hunter has served as organist since 2018. Hunter is also a professor of humanities at St. Petersburg College, where he has taught for more than 30 years.
Shannon Harmon-Greene directs student ministries after more than ten years of volunteering and working in children and youth ministry. She coordinates the Overflow nursery, primary and youth groups, and volunteers who want to give their time to children's ministry.
Those who cannot be in the room can still join the worship: services and messages from both Sunday services are available through the church's YouTube channel, and a sermon archive is kept there. Message notes, weekly bulletins and updates on upcoming events keep families connected to the teaching and to one another.
A Family Built Around Hope
St. Andrews describes itself as a family of individuals who have found hope in Jesus and simply want as many people as possible to experience that same freedom. Its story runs from a 1958 gathering in an orange juice plant to a Michigan Boulevard congregation that pairs a drum kit with a pipe organ, teaches preschoolers and teenagers in the same week, keeps adult groups meeting on Monday evenings, and sends members into food pantries, cold night shelters, school projects and mission trips. A seat is saved for anyone who walks in looking for a place to belong.