At the entrance to Marblehead, Wyman Memorial Church of St. Andrew stands on a hill in a traditional fieldstone sanctuary with hardwood furnishings and allegorical stained-glass windows. The Episcopal congregation opened its doors in 1924 and has developed a church life known for progressive worship shaped by Rite II, Anglican and contemporary music, and a wide circle of formation, art, care, and practical service to Marblehead and the wider North Shore.
A 1924 Beginning in Wyman’s Woods
The story of St. Andrew’s begins with Isaac Chauncy Wyman, a lifelong Salem resident and communicant of St. Michael’s in Marblehead. He owned a wooded tract bordering the Forest River that included the Wyman family burial plot. As the area developed, he became concerned that children had no Sunday school opportunity. In his 1910 will, Wyman left land and money for a memorial chapel where religious services, education for children of all denominations, and neighborhood social activities could take place. He directed that the offer go first to St. Michael’s, then to any Marblehead church if it did not act. Lyman Rollins, rector of St. Michael’s, received permission in 1922, and the original building was completed in the fall of 1924.
The congregation was organized that year as an Episcopal mission, with the Rev. David R. Haupt as curate in charge. Early lay members canvassed the neighborhood for children and choir members; by 1929, 109 children enrolled in the school. A parish hall stood before the church was consecrated in 1930. The building continued to grow, and a bell tower was added in 1964 through a bequest from Martha Higginson Hills. Its 1861 bell, made in Sheffield, England, had rung for Marblehead fires and called men to fight in the Civil War. Known as “Old Calamity,” the bell was eventually given a place of honor at St. Andrew’s.
Sunday Eucharist at 8 and 10
St. Andrew’s celebrates Rite II of the Episcopal liturgy at regular Sunday services at 8:00 a.m. and 10:00 a.m. The earlier service is spoken, while the 10:00 service includes hymns, choir, and organ. From June through August, and on the first Sunday in September, the congregation gathers for one musical service at 9:00 a.m. The 10:00 service is also available through the church’s YouTube livestream.
An usher greets people as they enter the sanctuary and provides a leaflet containing the day’s readings and spoken prayers. The smaller red Book of Common Prayer and the larger red Hymnal are available in each pew. Lay members take active roles as acolytes, lectors, chalice bearers, and ushers, while vestry members are available to answer questions before worship. Guest preachers occasionally participate in the services.
Everyone is welcome at the altar rail for the Eucharist. Congregants may receive bread with one open hand resting on the other and then sip from the chalice or dip the bread into the wine. Those who prefer not to receive communion may cross their arms for a blessing. Gluten-free wafers are available on quiet request. Children and families are fully part of worship: during the school year, church-school children join the congregation just before the Peace, and babies and toddlers are always welcome to remain with their families. Nursery care is not available during Sunday services.
Anglican Tradition with a Contemporary Reach
Music at the 10:00 service combines Anglican roots with contemporary offerings intended to inspire the whole congregation. The music ministry includes a dedicated choir, Music Director Christiana Goslin Bueno, Organist and Pianist Eleena Gelfgatt, and visiting musicians. Christiana is a soprano whose background combines classical vocal training, dance, musical theater, and a broad multicultural perspective. The choir welcomes singers of all experience levels and encourages musicians from the surrounding community to participate.
Music extends well beyond the Sunday choir. St. Andrew’s has a long history of concerts, cantatas, and performances by visiting ensembles. Its annual Good Friday Cantata has been presented for more than 40 years and combines music, storytelling, humor, and reflection. The church’s worship also welcomes art into the service, explores different liturgies, and makes room for different preaching styles.
Coffee Cups and Conversation Between Services
The Adult Forum meets most Sundays between services for conversation and reflection. On Tuesday mornings, Gospel Reflections Bible Study brings people together from 9:30 to 10:30 a.m. to explore the coming week’s Gospel through warm fellowship and discussion. Participants may come every week or occasionally. Lenten book discussions begin with a simple soup supper and are often held with other Marblehead congregations.
Dining Disciples helps parishioners move beyond the brief Peace at worship by forming small groups that meet several times a year for potluck meals in homes or the parish hall. Babysitting is often arranged so families with young children can join. Two or three times a year, the groups gather in the parish hall for community dessert.
Other regular gatherings include “This Magic Moment” Memory Café on alternate Tuesdays at 11:00 a.m. It offers a judgment-free setting through Zoom for people with memory loss and their caregivers. Coffee Cups meets on the second Saturday from 8:30 to 9:30 a.m. with coffee provided and a snack brought by participants. The Men’s Group meets monthly on Saturdays, and St. Andrews Around Town organizes walks, movies, coffee, lectures, and other activities chosen by participants.
Children, Youth and a Cooperative Nursery
Children are regarded as vital members of St. Andrew’s community and future, not as separate from the life of the congregation. The North Shore Youth Ministry, led by Youth Pastor Jess Easter, meets most Sundays for middle school students in grades 6 through 8 from 3:30 to 5:30 p.m. High school students in grades 9 through 12 gather from 6:00 to 8:00 p.m. The youth chose the name North Shore Youth Ministry, or NSYM, as part of the Marblehead Youth Collaborative Ministry.
St. Andrew’s has also used Godly Play for children’s Christian education. This Montessori-based approach uses storytelling, play, imagination, and hands-on engagement with biblical stories to invite questions and help children develop their spiritual lives. The church’s broader family life includes a cooperative nursery school located in the church building.
St. Andrew’s Cooperative Nursery School is a cooperative venture in which parents contribute time and talent to their children’s early education. Its goal is a preschool community that is socially, economically, and racially integrated and gives children the experience of learning with people from varied backgrounds. Church membership is not required for a child to attend.
Art on the Cloister Wall and a Path for Centering
The Cloister Art Gallery is open Monday through Thursday from 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. Visitors ring the doorbell at the far right door of the church for admittance, and the gallery is handicapped accessible. It presents work by local and visiting artists, including collaborative groups working in painting, photography, ceramics, printmaking, mosaic, jewelry, and mixed media. Children’s art is welcomed as well.
On the front lawn, a contemplative labyrinth offers a second way to experience the church grounds. The seven-ring, single-path design was built by a group of parishioners using stones from local beaches. People of all ages use the clearly marked route to the center and back as a practice of meditation and centering.
A Rummage Sale and Christmas Pageant Built for Participation
Twice a year, St. Andrew’s hosts a rummage sale that turns donated clothing, accessories, jewelry, home goods, toys, sporting goods, electronics, collectibles, and vintage items into affordable finds. The sale promotes sustainable shopping while directly supporting the church’s ministries and work with people in need. Its many volunteer roles include sorting, setup, publicity, cashiering, and cleanup.
A children’s Christmas Eve Pageant is another long-standing tradition. Children can arrive early and be assigned roles without auditions, memorization, or rehearsals. Simple costumes are provided, or families may bring their own, and the congregation joins in singing beloved Christmas carols during the retelling of the Nativity story.
Outreach That Starts with Food and Trust
St. Andrew’s Community Outreach Ministry supports people locally and abroad through parishioner contributions. Its work includes cash and food donations for local food pantries, funding for summer day care, scholarships for college and grade-school tuition, and monetary help for families struggling with rent, utilities, or medical bills. The ministry also provides holiday meals and gift cards for a local grocery store.
St. Andrew’s has a long record of service at My Brother’s Table, where parishioners volunteer on the third Wednesday of each month. The interfaith Welcome the Stranger partnership includes St. Andrew’s, Temple Emanu-El, and Old North Church. Together they have helped resettle asylum seekers and refugees by providing transportation, English as a Second Language instruction, help navigating education and health systems, and donated home furnishings. The partnership has also assisted people experiencing homelessness as they transition into permanent housing.
Since 2017, St. Andrew’s has hosted SPUR’s Community Roots garden, which was established in 2016 to grow fresh produce for area food pantries and community programs. The partnership helped the garden nearly triple in size and gives it greater stability. Its work connects people with fresh food grown without toxins and addresses barriers to healthy food.
The church has a long history of welcoming and supporting LGBTQIA neighbors, including through shared meals, the Salem Pride Parade, and participation with Nagly. Its other outreach includes Kids in Community, a free four-week summer camp in Lynn for elementary-age children. Campers take field trips, play outdoor games, take part in music and art activities, and have reading time, with adult reading buddies joining the program.
Pastoral Care and the Church’s Milestones
Pastoral care at St. Andrew’s includes hospital visits, home visits with Eucharist, and meal preparation for people facing different kinds of need. The clergy and staff help families plan funerals or memorial services and offer conversations or visits during times of grief. The church’s understanding of death is expressed in its proclamation that, in death, life is changed rather than ended, and that Christ is present with those who grieve.
Baptism is understood as a commitment to follow Jesus’ teaching of love and openness to God’s Spirit. Babies, children, youth, and adults may receive it, and baptisms take place several times a year during the main Sunday morning service. The parish community pledges support to each person and family beginning or continuing a Christian journey. Confirmation is a mature affirmation of the commitment made at baptism, and people confirmed in other denominations may be received into the Episcopal Church. Weddings, funerals, and memorials are also part of the church’s ministry, with weddings drawing on the historic chapel, event hall, and landscaped campus for ceremonies and receptions.
A Mission Extending Beyond the Parish
St. Andrew’s describes its mission as growing spiritually and reaching out to others as part of the global family. Its communal commitments include worship that strengthens and inspires, love and mutual care, Christian formation and discipleship, mission and outreach, and faithful stewardship of God’s creation and gifts. The congregation welcomes people from different religious traditions and perspectives, including those at every stage of belief, and expresses spirituality through fellowship, prayer, art, music, and social justice.
Stewardship supports that mission through annual pledges, one-time gifts, and planned legacy gifts. Pledges help the congregation plan its budget, community programming, pastoral care, and outreach. Giving is available through the church’s giving program, including checks, recurring bank payments, qualified charitable distributions, and gifts of securities. Legacy giving through a will, trust, retirement plan, or life insurance policy adds to the church’s endowment, which provides long-term support for worship, ministries, outreach, and operations. At St. Andrew’s, that mission remains a daily shape for worship and life: grow spiritually, welcome people of many backgrounds and traditions, strengthen fellowship and formation, care for people in times of need, and serve the wider community through practical partnership.