Need a website or online shop for your business? GetYourSite builds them from $24.99/month. Any small business · Half price for the first year, normally $49.99/month · Get 50% off

Shrewsbury's Presbyterian Church: Worship, Learning, and Service Since 1732

Presbyterian/Reformed Church in Shrewsbury, New Jersey

The Presbyterian Church at Shrewsbury, a congregation rooted in 1732, worships each Sunday at 10 a.m. in its historic sanctuary and through Zoom. Its ministries pair relaxed traditional worship with Christian education, music, family programs, social service, and longstanding community partnerships.

About Presbyterian Church-Shrewsbury

At 352 Sycamore Avenue in Shrewsbury, New Jersey, The Presbyterian Church at Shrewsbury is known for roots that reach to 1732, a white sanctuary with red doors, and a church life that joins traditional worship to education, music, service, and civic hospitality. Sunday worship begins at 10 a.m. in the sanctuary and through Zoom, while the adjoining Church House opens its rooms to families, adults, nonprofits, and community groups.

From Private Homes to the White Sanctuary

Shrewsbury was founded in 1685 by Scottish Presbyterians who initially gathered for worship in private homes. The itinerant minister John Boyd, described as the first Presbyterian minister ordained in this country, preached in Shrewsbury as early as 1705. The congregation was formalized in 1732, and its first church building rose in 1735 on land deeded by Nicholas Brown for a church and burial ground.

The Revolution tested the congregation's commitment. The Rev. Charles McKnight arranged a $600 loan of church money to the new government, money never repaid, was arrested for preaching sedition and revolution, and spent two years in prison before dying from injuries and sickness sustained there. The original church burned in 1800. For the next 20 years, Presbyterians worshiped next door at Christ Church, developing an association that changed one familiar custom: they began saying trespasses rather than debts in the Lord's Prayer, a tradition kept until about 1960.

The cornerstone of the present sanctuary was laid in 1821, and the building was completed the next year. Its bell tower came in the 1840s, the Social Room was added in 1895, and the steeple was raised in 1964. A royal charter granted in 1750 by Governor Jonathan Belcher, in the name of King George II, recognized the Presbyterian Church's right to exist and hold property in Monmouth County. The church's corporate seal pairs a burning bush with the motto Religious Liberty and a star with eight points; it is the oldest known corporate seal of an American Presbyterian church.

Sunday at Ten: Traditional, but Relaxed

The Sunday service follows a consistent order of worship and has a traditional but relaxed style. Three hymns usually come from a hymnal, with contemporary texts and music added at times. The service opens and closes with music for organ, piano, handbells, or other instrumentalists, giving worshipers space to center themselves, reflect, and turn toward God. A worship bulletin supplies the spoken and sung responses, and the congregation takes an active part.

Each service includes time for sharing joys and concerns. The Rev. Katja Gruening preaches most Sundays, often applying Scripture's themes of God's love, compassion, and justice to life in the contemporary world. Offering plates are passed near the end, but visitors and guests are never expected to give. The service also makes room for creative arts and reflection from time to time. Artist Will Ross painted a Genesis 1 creation mural for the church, extending that visual dimension of worship.

Annual services include Thanksgiving, Advent and Christmas, Holy Week and Easter, and a joint Independence Day service with Christ Episcopal Church. The church's musical life also shapes the arc of Sunday morning: the Chancel Choir rehearses at 8:30 a.m. and sings in worship twice a month, while the Jubilee Bell Choir rings about once a month.

An Open Table and a Welcome That Reaches Wide

Communion is celebrated on the first Sunday of every month. The table is open: Presbyterians, members of other denominations, Roman Catholics, people who are not church members, people who have not been baptized, and young children are all welcome. Gluten-free bread is always available, and grape juice is used so all may participate. Those worshiping through Zoom may join with their own bread and drink at home.

The congregation's convictions center on the sovereignty of God, Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, and the Holy Spirit's transforming work in the world and in believers. Baptism and the Lord's Supper are its two sacraments. The Bible is the authoritative witness to the Word of God, read under the Spirit's inspiration. The true church is understood as the gathering of Christ's people that faithfully proclaims God's Word and practices love of God and neighbor.

The congregation also identifies as Reformed and Reforming, guided by a series of confessions rather than a rigid set of adopted doctrines. Its constitution emphasizes the Word of God, shared responsibility, accountability, transparency, and connection to the larger body of Christ.

This understanding shapes an inclusive fellowship. The church welcomes people across gender, sexual orientation, race, ethnicity, nationality, neurodiversity, disability, economic status, and Christian belief. Members are not required to confess a particular doctrine, only faith in Christ. At the same time, the church calls Presbyterians to ethical engagement through charity and social witness, including concern for poverty, violence, climate change, immigrants, the LGBTQIA+ community, and people of color.

Finding the Church and Settling In

The sanctuary is the white church with red doors reached by following the sidewalk from the Church House parking lot to Sycamore Avenue and turning left. An usher will help visitors find a seat, locate the restrooms, answer questions, and provide a worship bulletin. Parking surrounds the Church House at 352 Sycamore Avenue. Additional street parking is available along the shoulder opposite the sanctuary and in front of the manse, beginning past the hydrant.

Accessible parking is directly in front of the Church House, whose front doors have level access. All but the second floor Children's Sunday School rooms can be reached without stairs. The sanctuary has a ramp at its side door and a small number of parking spaces in the driveway immediately west of the ramp. The sanctuary includes two individual restrooms, one with grab bars and ample room for mobility aids. The Church House has an accessible individual restroom with grab bars and a baby-changing table, plus larger accessible stalls in the men's and women's restrooms.

Visitors can wear whatever feels comfortable. Jeans and ties, sneakers and dress shoes are all common. Most services last about an hour, while the first Sunday of the month runs about 15 minutes longer because of Communion. Afterward, Coffee Hour takes place in Fellowship Hall in the Church House, with coffee, tea, juice, and sweet and savory snacks. In summer, lighter refreshments are served in the Social Room behind the sanctuary.

Children Join the Congregation

Children of every age are welcome in worship. Babies can be brought into the service, and parents are free to tend to them or step out without apology. Young children may play with quiet toys, draw, or move around; parents with reading-age children are encouraged to help them follow the bulletin and hymnal. A Kids Zone near the front gives children a place to sit with teachers and activity sheets, and a brief children's message is offered on the first and third Sundays from September through June.

There is no staffed nursery, but the nursery in the education wing of the Church House is available to parents of infants and toddlers who need a break. The family restroom on the first floor has a baby-changing table.

Sunday School meets from 10:00 to 11:15 a.m. on the first and third Sundays from September through June for ages 5 to 12, or kindergarten through fifth grade. Families first worship together for about 20 minutes, after which teachers lead children to classes for Bible stories, crafts, games, and activities that help the stories take root. Each class takes on an annual mission project, using funds raised through the monthly Noisy Offering and deciding together how to help others.

Kidz Club meets once a month on Wednesday evenings from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. in Fellowship Hall. Its camp-style evening includes games, dinner, songs, crafts, and Bible stories, with plenty of room to run and play. Older children and teens can join the Youth Leadership Program, serve as readers, candlelighters, communion servers, greeters, or musicians, and prepare for full membership through Confirmation Class. Recurring seasonal gatherings include a backpack blessing, Christmas pageant, Easter egg hunt, and Youth Sunday.

Learning in Conversation, Prayer, and Fellowship

Adult Bible Study meets on Zoom from 9:00 to 10:00 a.m. Tuesday mornings from September through June. Led by Pastor Katja, it is conversation-based, with a study book provided, and participants may drop in or make it a regular part of their week. A seasonal prayer group gathers Wednesdays from 7:00 to 9:00 p.m. for those who want to deepen their prayer life alongside others. Adults may also volunteer as liturgists, reading Scripture and leading prayers in Sunday and special services.

Friendship has its own regular forms. Dorcas' Circle, the women's group, meets monthly for fellowship and a changing activity. The men's group meets for breakfast at a local diner on the first Saturday of each month. Gentle yoga meets weekly at 10:45 a.m. Thursday in the Church House, is free and open to all, and accommodates different levels of mobility. Past and present interest groups have included books, cooking, travel, and movies.

Choir, Handbells, and Music in Worship

Music is directed by Marcello Velame and described as vital to worship and prayer because it draws people near God, gives shape to belief, supports contemplation, builds unity, and carries what words cannot express. The Chancel Choir rehearses Sundays from 8:30 to 9:15 a.m. during its ministry season. It sings mostly easy to moderate music in two or three voice parts and welcomes singers at every experience level.

The Jubilee Bell Choir rehearses Thursdays from 6:00 to 7:00 p.m. Its five octaves of Malmark handbells and three octaves of choir chimes ring mostly moderate to advanced music, though the choir has tutored and welcomed new ringers. Both choirs sing or ring in worship about twice a month and at Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter.

Vocal and instrumental soloists, guest musicians, and the occasional pop-up Project SING for advanced community singers add further variety. The music ministry welcomes people with varied gifts and musical tastes.

Serving Shrewsbury and the Wider Community

The church's service life is both local and far-reaching. PCAS collects food throughout the year for the Eatontown Food Pantry and supports its CROP Walk team, the Center in Asbury Park, NJ Blood Services, Love Thy Neighbor, Interfaith Neighbors, Trinity Center for Community, and local warming and cooling shelters. Food donations, volunteer work, mission giving, and special offerings are directed toward local, national, and global needs.

The church's buildings give room to community life. The immigrant congregation Igreja Presbiteriana Getsemani, Scouting America Troop and Pack 50, Alcoholics Anonymous, Overeaters Anonymous, the Mental Health Association of Monmouth County, and Shrewsbury Senior Homesteaders are among the organizations hosted there. The church also houses groups that have gathered for Scouting, theater, twelve-step programs, weight-loss organizations, and PFLAG.

Among the congregation's national and global commitments are One Great Hour of Sharing for hunger and disaster assistance, Peace and Global Witness, Christmas Joy, the Sunday School's Noisy Offering, Hope Haitian School, Kids Alive, Operation Christmas Child, and a rotating slate of international aid organizations. Mission giving also includes care packages for children in the Dominican Republic.

Lasting partnerships deepen the church's local ties. PCAS and Monmouth Reform Temple have shared an annual Thanksgiving worship service for more than 60 years. The church joins Christ Episcopal Church, the Quaker Meeting of Shrewsbury, the Shrewsbury Historical Society, and the Borough of Shrewsbury for the Four Corners observance. With Integrated Medicine Alliance, it hosts blood drives that combine the church's facilities with the group's community reach. Gifts support worship, education, charity, service, community building, and nonprofit organizations that improve lives. The church describes generosity as part of its social witness and responds to natural and human disasters as they occur. Online giving supports the general mission, while designated gifts can be arranged for particular ministries.

A Cemetery with Three Centuries of Memory

The cemetery contains graves dating to the early 1700s and has served as a Christian burial ground for 300 years. It remains private for burials, but families are welcome to tend graves, and visitors interested in the cemetery's history or ancestry are welcome to explore it. More than 100 veterans are buried there. The Shrewsbury chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution has installed markers for known patriots and organizes service days to clean and preserve historic grave markers. The Memorial Garden recognizes veterans through an Eagle Scout project.

The sanctuary's history includes a commitment written into the 1821 resolution for its construction: the doors would open to all denominations that made Jesus Christ the foundation of their immortal hopes. That spirit continues through the church's own worship, community organizations, interfaith relationships, and commitment to care for the surrounding community.

Pastoral Leadership for a Welcoming, Active Church

Pastor Katja Gruening wants the church to be a safe, affirming place for people with large doubts and deep questions, those disillusioned by church, and those seeking to explore and grow in Christian faith. She describes her ministry as putting faith into action through social witness, charity, and community outreach. A minister of Presbyterian churches in Michigan before coming to Shrewsbury, she earned her Master of Divinity at Princeton Theological Seminary and also trained in piano performance at the College of Wooster. Her approach emphasizes servant leadership, humility, creativity, and joy.

Spiritual leadership is shared by the pastor and Session elders elected by the congregation. The church also assigns deacons a particular role in caring for people during illness and personal crisis, while describing love as the heart of every meeting, activity, service, and task behind the scenes. Youth and family programs are led by Sherri Laberdee, a Certified Christian Educator, and music by Marcello Velame.

The Presbyterian Church at Shrewsbury continues to be both connectional and local: part of a presbytery, a synod, and the Presbyterian Church (USA), while keeping daily life centered on worship, learning, music, care, and welcome. At 352 Sycamore Avenue, its white sanctuary, Church House, cemetery, and community relationships form a visible expression of a faith that has served Shrewsbury since 1732.

Frequently asked questions

When does Sunday worship take place?

Sunday worship begins at 10:00 a.m. in the Sanctuary and is also available through Zoom. Most services last about an hour; the first Sunday of each month runs about 15 minutes longer for Communion.

What is Sunday worship like?

The service follows the same order each week in a traditional but relaxed style. Three hymns are usually sung from a hymnal, with contemporary music added at times. Congregational responses are active, and the service includes prayers, music, and a time for sharing joys and concerns.

What should visitors wear?

Wear whatever feels comfortable. Jeans and ties, sneakers and dress shoes are all common.

Are children welcome in worship?

Children of all ages are welcome. Babies and young children may stay with their parents, and a Kids Zone offers activity sheets. A children's message is offered on the first and third Sundays from September through June.

Is there childcare?

There is no staffed nursery. Parents of infants and toddlers may use the nursery in the Church House education wing if they need a break, and the first-floor family restroom has a baby-changing table.

What parking and accessibility are available?

Parking is available around the Church House and along the street shoulder opposite the Sanctuary. Accessible parking is in front of the Church House, which has level entry. The Sanctuary has a side-door ramp and nearby limited parking, and accessible restrooms are available in both buildings.

When is Communion celebrated?

Communion is celebrated on the first Sunday of each month with an open table. Everyone is welcome to participate. Gluten-free bread is always available, and grape juice is used.

What happens after worship?

Coffee Hour follows in Fellowship Hall in the Church House, with coffee, tea, juice, and sweet and savory snacks. During summer, lighter refreshments are served in the Social Room behind the Sanctuary.

Explore more churches

Looking somewhere else? Find churches near any ZIP code, city or address:

Plan your visit

Location on Map

Loading map…

Location Information

  • Address 352 Sycamore Ave, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
  • County Monmouth County
  • Area code 732
  • Time zone EST (observes DST)
  • PMSA 5190
  • FIPS 34025