Need a website or online shop for your business? GetYourSite builds them from $24.99/month. Any small business · Half price for the first year, normally $49.99/month · Get 50% off

Downtown by History and by Choice: First Presbyterian Church of Durham

Presbyterian/Reformed Church in Durham, North Carolina

First Presbyterian Church is a Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) congregation organized on New Year's Eve 1871 at the corner of Main and Roxboro Streets in downtown Durham, North Carolina. With around 575 members, the church is known for its 11:00 AM Sunday worship, an active social ministry, the in-house First Presbyterian Day School, and a long commitment to remain downtown by history and by choice.

About First Presbyterian Church

First Presbyterian Church sits at 305 East Main Street in downtown Durham, North Carolina, near the corner where Main Street meets Roxboro Street. Organized on New Year's Eve 1871, it is the oldest of the ten Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) congregations in the city. Generations of members describe the parish as "downtown by history and by choice" - a phrase first uttered when twentieth century suburbanization tempted many downtown congregations to migrate with their members, and a phrase the church continues to live by.

A Beacon at Main and Roxboro Since 1871

The first frame meetinghouse of First Presbyterian opened in 1876 on the corner that would become one of Durham's most recognizable intersections. By 1890 a much larger brick edifice with a steeple had taken its place, designed to seat a growing congregation drawn to the industrial city of the New South. Under pastors Henry T. Darnall (1880-1893) and Lennox B. Turnbull (1894-1901), the church planted "mill missions" that vastly expanded Presbyterianism in Durham. The Pearl Mill Chapel evolved into Trinity Avenue Presbyterian Church, the West Durham Chapel at Erwin Mills became Blacknall Memorial, and Edgemont Chapel became Fuller Memorial. In 1895 the first foreign mission field opened in central Brazil, soon followed by Soonchun, Korea, and later by partnerships in Africa and Cuba.

The early twentieth century brought physical and institutional growth, much of it seeded by the generosity of tobacco and textile magnate George Washington Watts. The Sunday School wing rose in 1913, the present sanctuary in 1916, and the present church house in 1923. The pastorate of Edward Leyburn (1902-1919) ushered in an expanded campus; the ministry of David Scanlon (1921-1938) made the downtown church a hub of the city's religious life through Prohibition, debates over biological evolution, and the Great Depression, while the Session pushed for more democratic church government.

John H. Marion (1938-1940), Kelsey Regen (1941-1960), and longtime church hostess Clara P. Matthis (1940-1969) guided the congregation through World War II and the postwar years, reaching out to the flood of soldiers stationed at nearby Camp Butner. In 1954, fifteen years before her own denomination permitted it, First Presbyterian's Session overtured Granville Presbytery to ordain and install women as ruling elders and deacons. A year later, in 1955, the church seated all who sought to worship, beginning an explicit commitment to inclusion across race, nationality, gender, ability, and economic circumstance that has shaped the congregation ever since.

As downtown Durham was reshaped by industrial decline, urban renewal, and suburban flight, First Presbyterian reaffirmed its stay at Roxboro and Main. The Christian Education Building was completed in 1964. The Rev. David Currie (1963-1968) arrived as the city wrestled with civil rights marches, an unpopular war, and cultural upheaval, and the Session received its first Black member of the modern era in 1964. Wallace Alston Jr. (1969-1974) and Samuel R. Hope (1975-1979), alongside a generation of associate ministers, expanded the urban mission that became a hallmark of the parish.

In 1970 the church opened its Child Care Center, today known as the First Presbyterian Day School. The long pastorate of the Rev. Joseph S. Harvard (1980-2013) deepened links with Durham's African American community, helped charter Iglesia Presbyteriana Emanuel from the former Northgate Presbyterian Church, and supported the development of Habitat for Humanity and Durham Congregations in Action. A 2002 capital campaign, "Remember, Renew, Rejoice," brought major renovations to the sanctuary, lighting, and sound, and a new elevator rendered the sanctuary, the church basement, and the Christian Education Building accessible to all. A 2010 set of "Plumb Line" core values made explicit the church's public commitments, and an Anti-Racism Policy was adopted by the Session in 2024.

In February 2016, after 33 years, First Presbyterian called its first woman senior pastor and its first senior minister called by the congregation in a generation, the Rev. Mindy L. Douglas. The Rev. John Weicher (2019-) and the Rev. Esther Hethcox (2022-) joined her as associate ministers, and together they led the congregation into its sesquicentennial year (1871-2021). The COVID-19 pandemic interrupted in-person worship after the Second Sunday in Lent 2020 and reshaped the planned capital campaign for the season. In-person worship resumed, with masks, on June 20, 2021.

Sunday Worship at Eleven

The congregation gathers each Sunday at 11:00 AM in the 1916 sanctuary for its principal service. The liturgy follows a Reformed shape of Word and Sacrament, with choir music, congregational hymnody, prayers, scripture readings, and a sermon. Communion is celebrated several times a year; the sacrament is open to all. The service is livestreamed on the church's YouTube channel for those unable to attend in person.

Just outside the sanctuary, in the narthex, a changing table and shelves of children's books are kept ready, and worship bags and interactive bulletins are available from ushers for younger children. Children are always welcome in worship, and parents may keep infants and small children with them throughout the service. During the hour, childcare is offered for infants through age five on the second floor of the Education Building; the church's child and youth protection policy keeps two caretakers in every classroom, and the caretakers can reach ushers during worship when parents need to be found. Children ages three through six are invited forward for "A Time with the Children" after the sermon and may remain in the sanctuary or return to the childcare space for the rest of worship. Large print bulletins are available.

The sanctuary seats 280 to 370 on the main floor, with another 36 to 48 in the balcony and 32 to 40 in the choir area. The main parking lot sits behind the sanctuary, entered from Roxboro and Liberty Streets (GPS address: 300 East Liberty Street, Durham, NC 27701) and includes accessible spaces. On Sunday mornings, additional free parking lots in the neighborhood open to First Presbyterian visitors.

Music at the Heart of Worship

Three volunteer choirs and a notable collection of instruments support the 11:00 AM service. The Chancel Choir, made up of volunteers with no audition, sings at worship throughout the year and at special services, rehearsing on Wednesday evenings from 7:00 to 8:00 during the academic year with childcare available for choir parents. The Children's Choir, open to children from kindergarten through fifth grade, rehearses after the Sunday service during the academic year and sings from memory roughly every six weeks. The Handbell Choir brings together musicians of various ages for rehearsal on Mondays at 5:00 PM during the academic year; the choir plays three octaves of English handbells cast by the Whitechapel Bell Foundry of London.

The instruments tell their own story. The organ was built in 1916 by the Austin Organ Company of Hartford, Connecticut (opus 581), with tonal upgrades and additional ranks of pipes added in 1964. Three manuals, a pedal keyboard, and forty stops - thirty-six at the front of the church, four in the antiphonal organ in the rear gallery - make up the instrument. The sanctuary piano acquired in 1998 is a Yamaha C5 6'7" conservatory grand, and the harpsichord delivered in 2005 is a Franco-Flemish double-manual instrument built by Willard Martin of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, patterned after a Nicolas Blanchet prototype of circa 1720.

Seasonal services punctuate the church year. On Wednesdays in Advent and Lent the congregation gathers for a 6:00 PM worship with communion, followed by a 6:30 PM light supper. A Service of Lessons and Carols, modeled on the King's College Chapel tradition, is observed on the third Sunday of Advent, and a Christmas Eve family service with communion and candlelight begins at 5:00 PM. The Music on Main series has welcomed guest performers over the years, including the Norwich Cathedral Girls' Choir, the Women's Chorus of Chapel Hill, harpsichordist Elaine Funaro, organist Shayne Doty, and jazz vocalist Nnenna Freelon.

Faith Formation for Every Age

From 9:45 to 10:45 AM each Sunday, between arrival and the 11:00 service, the church opens its Sunday morning program for all ages.

Adults can choose from three regular classes. The Adult Lectionary Class, meeting in the Robert Daye Meeting Room and via Zoom, walks through the four scripture texts appointed for the day's worship using the Revised Common Lectionary. The Faith and Community class gathers in Watts-Hill Hall to explore the intersection of Christian faith and Durham life, often welcoming outside speakers. Journeys meets in Wilson Parlor for an in-depth study of scripture using both printed and online resources. Meaning in the Middle (MnMs) is a Sunday evening small group for adults in the middle of life, meeting at 8:00 PM on Zoom to share the ups and downs of life and discuss a short reading about faith; the group also gathers monthly at a local brewery or for potlucks.

Children in preschool through fifth grade meet in three classes - preschool through kindergarten, kindergarten through second grade, and third through fifth grade - in age-appropriate rooms on Sunday mornings. The third-through-fifth-grade room uses Godly Play, presenting Bible stories with small props and inviting "Wondering" questions. Music for Children, led by the Director of Children's Ministry, gathers at 9:45 for twenty minutes of songs before Faith Formation. An outdoor preschool-through-second-grade option is offered on the playground when the weather allows. The Things That Matter book group gathers on the second Tuesday of selected months to discuss books on issues of concern.

Youth and Summer Trips

The youth ministry, led by the Associate Pastor for Youth and Their Families, welcomes young people in grades six through twelve. Sunday morning Faith Formation for youth meets in a downstairs youth room; the class follows the Follow Me curriculum, exploring practices such as joy, generosity, and crossing borders. Confirmation classes are offered every other year for current eighth and ninth graders (and any older high schoolers who have not yet been confirmed), beginning in November of odd-numbered years and culminating in May with a written statement of faith and a class confession of faith. On most Sunday evenings from September through early May, the youth group gathers from 5:00 to 7:00 PM for a blend of service, recreation, learning, Sabbath, and worship.

Every summer the youth ministry organizes four trips. Middle schoolers attend the Charleston Youth Mission service trip and the Massanetta Springs Middle School Conference, while high schoolers travel with Appalachia Service Project for a week of critical home repair and to the Montreat Youth Conference in the North Carolina mountains.

Six Doors of Outreach

An active social ministry program is the hallmark of First Presbyterian. The church's outreach is organized around six biblical priorities.

Feed the Hungry, Quench the Thirst, Welcome the Least

First Presbyterian supports Urban Ministries of Durham (UMD), just a block from the church. Volunteers prepare and serve hot breakfast on the third and fifth Friday of each month from 7:00 to 9:00 AM, and they prepare sandwiches for bag lunches on the third Monday and the fourth Thursday of each month from 9:30 to 10:30 AM. UMD's community café serves three meals a day, seven days a week. The congregation also participates in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) One Great Hour of Sharing offering (with a third of the receipts dedicated to hunger through the Presbyterian Hunger Program), the Presbytery of New Hope "Hunger for Change" collection at each end-of-month worship, and Meals on Wheels of Durham, which the church has supported financially and with volunteer drivers for more than forty years.

The Walk-In Ministry offers encouragement, referrals, limited financial assistance (up to $150 per household per year toward a utility or rent bill), and prayer to Durham neighbors experiencing financial instability. Volunteer caseworkers are reached by leaving a name and telephone number on the church's main line on Monday or Thursday mornings between 9:00 AM and noon; they return calls within forty-eight hours.

House the Homeless, Break the Yokes

Members were instrumental in establishing Genesis Home in 1989, now part of Families Moving Forward, and helped found Housing for New Hope in the 1990s. The church sponsors builds with Durham Habitat for Humanity; volunteers travel to Honduras each year to build alongside Habitat families; and the church has sent disaster response teams to the Gulf Coast and other regions through the Presbyterian Disaster Assistance program. The First Presbyterian Prison Ministry launched its first Faith Team in 2017 to walk alongside a person returning from the Durham County detention system, and congregation members also serve through Yokefellow at the Orange County Correctional Center. The Religious Coalition for a Nonviolent Durham partners with the church on these efforts, and the Durham County Criminal Justice Resource Center provides training.

Teach a Child, Transform the World

The First Presbyterian Day School, established in 1970 and housed in the church building, is a five-star rated, non-profit, non-sectarian program serving infants through four-year-olds from racially, culturally, and economically diverse backgrounds. StepUp Durham receives financial and volunteer support, as does Partners for Youth Opportunity, which mentors Durham students in workforce development, academic support, mentoring, and leadership. Globally, the church supports the South Sudan Presbyterian World Mission Partnership; mission worker Leisa Wagstaff, whose stateside home sits just thirty miles north of Durham, has spent decades teaching teachers across Central and East Africa.

Be One in the Spirit

The church partners locally with Iglesia Presbyteriana Emanuel, a Hispanic ministry chartered by the Presbytery of New Hope in 2016 that shares a building with Durham Presbyterian Church on North Roxboro Street. First Presbyterian volunteers help stock and distribute groceries at its Monday through Wednesday food pantry (which serves an average of 620 families each week) and tutor Hispanic students from first grade through high school on Tuesday and Thursday evenings. The church also partners with the Presbyterian Campus Ministry at Duke University, which touches more than four hundred students each year, and with the Presbyterian Campus Ministry at North Carolina Central University, and contributes annually to the Kenya Mission Network, the Democratic Republic of Congo mission network, and the South Sudan mission partnership.

The First Presbyterian Quilters make a hand-stitched quilt for every child baptized in the church under the age of three and contribute thirty to forty quilts each year to the Honduras mission trips. The church also supports disaster response teams, Presbyterian Campus Ministry at Duke and NCCU, and a long-running partnership with Habitat for Humanity.

Advocate for Justice, Work for Peace

First Presbyterian is a founding member of Durham Congregations in Action and an active member of Durham CAN, a broad-based coalition of congregations, associations, and neighborhoods that has campaigned for affordable housing, jobs, public transit, school resources for immigrant families, and livable wages. Members participate in End Poverty Durham, whose REAL Durham initiative pairs neighbors in material poverty with community allies. The Racial Equity Task Force reads, studies, and acts on racial justice locally and led the Presbytery of New Hope to a resolution on ending cash bail in North Carolina. Care Teams for Reentry walk alongside individuals returning from incarceration through the Religious Coalition for a Nonviolent Durham. Each fall the church receives the Peace and Global Witness Offering, with twenty-five percent of the receipts retained by First Presbyterian for its own peace ministries. The church also supports the North Carolina Council of Churches, founded in 1935, on issues from environmental justice to gun violence prevention to immigrants' rights.

Creation Care

First Presbyterian is an official PC(USA) Earth Care Congregation, having affirmed the Earth Care Pledge in 2020. A monthly Creation Care group weaves environmental stewardship into worship, education, facilities, and outreach, and the church supports a Community Supported Agriculture partnership with Sankofa Farms in Efland, a farm of color, in collaboration with RAFI-USA's Farm and Faith Partnerships Project and two other local congregations.

Pastoral Care, Fellowship, and Open Doors

The Pastoral Care Committee coordinates the church's response to illness, loss, and crisis, including a weekly flower ministry to brighten the day of a member in need, meal trains for households in difficult seasons, and visits during hospitalization. A knitting group makes prayer shawls for those in hard times, plus scarves for confirmation students and graduating seniors.

Fellowship circles meet across the life span. Presbyterian Women gathers the first Monday of each month for Bible study using the Presbyterian Women Horizon Bible Study, prayer, and fellowship. Men of Faith meets the first Friday of the month for breakfast at Mad Hatters Café on West Main Street. The Daytimers, a mostly retired group, meets monthly for lunch at rotating Durham restaurants. First Friends, open to all adults, gathers almost monthly for potluck meals, games, or hikes. The Somethings, a community of adults in their twenties and thirties, gathers for home meals, pop-up brewery evenings, Advent and Lent devotional series, and social justice opportunities. Yoga is offered free of charge on Mondays at 4:30 PM (a vinyasa flow class) and Fridays at 10:30 AM (chair yoga), with mats and blocks provided.

The church has been a member of the Covenant Network of Presbyterians since 2003, and its members serve on boards and committees across Durham's faith and nonprofit landscape. An annual Stewardship campaign, a designated Legacy Society for planned giving, and a robust online donation system support the work of the congregation; the church also underwrites its own direct debit, text giving, appreciated stock, and IRA charitable distribution options for those who wish to give in those ways.

Weddings, the Building, and a Day School Downstairs

First Presbyterian hosts weddings for both members and guests. Reservations for guest weddings may be made up to ten months in advance. The sanctuary seats up to roughly four hundred for a service, and the 1916 sanctuary organ, the English handbells, and the harpsichord make for a striking musical setting. The Watts-Hill Fellowship Hall, the renovated kitchen, and the Memorial Garden are part of the long-term plan for hospitality, and the building is in regular use by community groups through the church's Building Use program. The First Presbyterian Day School shares the building with the church and adds a daily rhythm of children, teachers, and families to the parish's life.

Eight Core Values as Plumb Line

The congregation has summarized its calling in eight "Plumb Line" core values, adopted and refined over the years: Reformed Worship through a shared liturgy of Word and Sacrament; Diversity and Inclusivity, claiming and nurturing all of God's people in baptism; Faith Exploration at every point on the journey with the Risen Christ; Pastoral Care that loves as God has loved; Historic Placement as "a witness to God's steadfast love and justice in the heart of the city"; Social Mission advocating for justice and responding to the cries of the poor; Faithful Stewardship of every gift God has given; and Community as a reflection of God's beloved community.

The church has spoken publicly on matters of public witness in the spirit of the Beatitudes, calling itself to be "a city built upon a hill" in a world that values wealth, profits from war, and persecutes prophetic dissent. The Session's Anti-Racism Policy commits the congregation to ongoing work against racism in the life of the church and the wider city, and a Racial Equity Task Force continues the work of reading, visiting, and acting on behalf of racial justice in Durham.

Pastoral Leadership

The pastoral team is led by the Rev. Mindy Douglas as Pastor and Head of Staff, the Rev. Esther Hethcox as Associate Pastor, and the Rev. John Weicher as Associate Pastor for Youth and Their Families. The Rev. Susan Dunlap serves as Parish Associate. Matthew Moore leads music as Minister of Music, and Lenore Champion directs the children's ministry. The Rev. Joseph S. Harvard serves as Pastor Emeritus after his long ministry of 1980 to 2013. The Session (the ruling body of elders), the Diaconate, and a wide range of committees carry on the governance of the congregation under Reformed Presbyterian polity.

From its corner at Main and Roxboro, First Presbyterian continues to be what it has called itself for more than 150 years: downtown by history and by choice, a witness to God's steadfast love and justice in the heart of Durham.

Frequently asked questions

What time is Sunday worship at First Presbyterian?

The 11:00 AM Sunday worship is the principal service. Faith Formation classes for adults, youth, and children are offered on Sunday mornings from 9:45 to 10:45 AM.

Is the service livestreamed?

Yes. The 11:00 AM service is livestreamed on the church's YouTube channel.

Where do I park?

The main parking lot is behind the sanctuary, entered from Roxboro and Liberty Streets (GPS address 300 East Liberty Street, Durham, NC 27701); it includes accessible parking spaces. On Sunday mornings additional free lots near the church open to First Presbyterian visitors.

Are children welcome in worship?

Children are always welcome in worship. Worship bags and interactive bulletins are available from ushers, and childcare is provided on the second floor of the Education Building for infants through age five during worship. Children ages three through six are invited forward for "A Time with the Children" following the sermon.

What denomination is First Presbyterian?

First Presbyterian is a congregation of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) within the New Hope Presbytery.

How do I get involved?

The church offers many ways to serve - from Urban Ministries of Durham breakfasts and the Walk-In Ministry to the choirs and handbells, children's and youth programs, advocacy groups such as Durham CAN and the Racial Equity Task Force, and monthly landscaping days. Contact the church office at (919) 682-5511 to be matched with an opportunity.

How do I inquire about a wedding?

Guest weddings may be reserved up to ten months in advance through the wedding coordinator; the church office can be reached at (919) 682-5511 for all wedding inquiries. Member weddings follow the church's currently approved member guidelines.

Is the building accessible?

Yes. Following a 2002 renovation, an elevator and other improvements made the sanctuary, the church basement, and the Christian Education Building accessible. The main parking lot includes accessible spaces, and large print worship bulletins are available.

Explore more churches

Looking somewhere else? Find churches near any ZIP code, city or address:

Plan your visit

Location on Map

Loading map…

Location Information

  • Address 305 E Main St, Durham, NC 27701
  • County Durham County
  • Area code 919
  • Time zone EST (observes DST)
  • Metro area (MSA) 6640
  • FIPS 37063