A Norwegian-Settler Lutheran Church in the Village of Cooksville
Cooksville Lutheran Church has gathered for Christian worship in the small village of Cooksville, a few miles northwest of Evansville, Wisconsin, since 1891. The church at 11927 West Church Street still carries the marks of its Norwegian Lutheran beginnings, from the constitution adopted at the founding meeting to the lefse and meatloaf suppers that fill the fellowship area each fall. Today the congregation belongs to the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) within the South-Central Synod of Wisconsin, and Pastor Elizabeth Lippke-Ganzel now serves as pastor.
From a Schoolhouse Meeting to a Rebuilt Sanctuary
The story begins with the Norwegian families among Cooksville's early settlers. Many of the village's pioneers had come from Massachusetts, but a smaller group of Norwegian Lutherans wanted a spiritual home of their own rather than the long ride into Stoughton. Their wish set things in motion on October 15, 1891, when twenty-one of twenty-three residents gathered in the Cooksville schoolhouse and adopted the constitution of the United Norwegian Lutheran Church. The Reverend Theodor H. Dahl agreed to come preach every third Sunday, for an annual salary of $125 plus festival offerings. The first church was built during the spring and summer of 1892, but lightning struck the building on September 18, 1896, and it burned to the ground. With insurance covering most of the $2,339 loss and $1,800 already in the treasury, the congregation rebuilt, and the new church was completed in 1897.
Reverend Dahl gave his farewell sermon on Easter Sunday 1903. He was followed by the Reverend M. H. Hegge, who held Norwegian services on Sunday afternoons. Under Pastor Hegge, the women of the Kvinneforening (Ladies' Aid Society) organized devotions, sewing, and the famous Norwegian lutefisk dinners. In 1964 the dinner fed about 1,200 people from 1,400 pounds of lutefisk, 200 pounds of meatballs, 1,200 pounds of lefse, 37 large kettles of potatoes, 135 pounds of butter, 38 pounds of coffee, 168 pies, 55 dozen dinner rolls, and 255 pounds of coleslaw. The last lutefisk dinner was served in October 1973, but the annual meatloaf dinner, bake sale, and lefse sale carry the tradition forward today.
Pastors and the Shape of the Parish
By 1936 the synod office decided that a Lutheran mission congregation should be established in Evansville, with Cooksville as the parent church, and the Reverend Theodore M. Heimarck was installed to serve the new Cooksville-Evansville parish. Heimarck organized the altar guild, choir, and Sunday School, and during his tenure the pulpit was replaced with a lectern, and new pews, altar rail, lighting, and colored windows in the nave came in. The Reverend A. M. Romstad was installed in 1942, and the late 1940s brought a west entrance, restrooms, choir room, pastor's study, new altar, and new windows. The building was rededicated on December 3, 1950.
By 1964 the Evansville congregation had grown to 800 members, and the synod dissolved the two-point parish. Cooksville then joined with Brooklyn Lutheran, and the Reverend Cyrl Jandery was installed that December. Under Jandery, a $15,000 remodeling project in 1966 removed the outside steps, replaced the heating system, added a new steeple, and added seating for twenty-five. Only five pastors had served Cooksville in its first eighty-seven years. Later pastors have included Elizabeth Druckery, Elizabeth Zentner, Richard Horst, Rodney Nordby, Margo Martens, Katya Ouchakof, and Karla Brekke, with interim pastors filling the years between.
Sunday Worship at Ten
Worship is held in person each Sunday at 10 a.m., with Holy Communion as a regular feature of the service. Services are streamed on Facebook when possible. Sunday School meets during the worship hour. On the first Sunday of each month, fellowship time follows the service and includes a recognition of members with birthdays that month. During the summer, the congregation moves outdoors for the third Sunday of June, July, and August, weather permitting; in case of inclement weather, worship moves indoors for that Sunday.
The sanctuary is described as a traditional setting enhanced by the church's organ and stained-glass windows. The church hosts both weddings and funerals.
A Building That Grew With the Congregation
Under Pastor Margo Martens, the congregation voted to make the building barrier-free. Ground was broken in 2009, and the finished 2010 addition houses the lift, a light-filled fellowship area, staff offices, restrooms, and a sacristy. The project was paid off by the following year. Earlier remodeling under Pastor Romstad had added a west entrance, bathrooms, choir room, pastor's study, new altar, and new windows, while the Jandery-era project added a new steeple, electric heating, additional seating, and a barrier-free entry on the north end.
Food Pantry, Quilts, and Prayer
A network of small but steady ministries anchors the week at Cooksville Lutheran. The church supports three local food pantries, with Sue Parsons serving as Food Pantry Coordinator. A mum sale each September benefits this outreach. The Quilters meet at the church on Mondays at 9 a.m. The Prayer Group gathers on Wednesdays at 10:30 a.m. The Maintenance Group meets on Thursdays at 9 a.m. The Church Council meets on the first Monday of each month at 7 p.m.
Sunday School is led by Jennifer Nelson, who also coordinates worship volunteers. Pastor Elizabeth and Phil Hamilton share leadership of Confirmation and First Communion classes. Adult Bible Study is coordinated by Betty Hamilton, and the Altar Guild by Pat Foltz. Music ministry is led by Music Director Jeanne Julseth and Accompanist Karen Kaehr.
Pastor Elizabeth Lippke-Ganzel
In January 2022, recent seminary graduate Elizabeth Lippke-Ganzel was called to Cooksville Lutheran. She was ordained in March and installed as the church's part-time pastor on May 22, 2022.
The church office can be reached at (608) 882-4408 or cooksvillelutheran@gmail.com. The mailing address is 11927 West Church Street, Evansville, WI 53536. People interested in becoming members are invited to contact the church office.