At 331 Lake Avenue in Maitland, The Episcopal Church of the Good Shepherd is known for two Sunday worship settings and a long record of neighborhood service. Its 1880 Carpenter Gothic chapel stands beside a modern main church, while its food pantry traces its roots to the church's beginnings and the needs of Seminole neighbors in Eatonville. The parish belongs to the Episcopal Diocese of Central Florida and the Anglican Communion, describing itself as a welcoming community of people young and old who hunger for the presence of Jesus.
Two Sundays, Two Episcopal Rites
- 8:00 a.m. The Sunday service uses Rite I in the Historic Chapel.
- 10:30 a.m. Holy Eucharist, Rite II, is celebrated in the Main Church with music.
All are welcome to worship, and the church offers to have someone sit with a visitor during a service and answer questions. All services follow the Book of Common Prayer and the Revised Common Lectionary, with sermons by the clergy. Together, the two services provide distinct forms of worship within the Episcopal tradition.
Recent sermons for the 10:30 a.m. service are available in the sermon archive, with the same ministry offered through an Apple Podcasts feed.
The 1880 Carpenter Gothic Chapel
The original church was built in 1880 to designs by New York architect Charles C. Haight. Its Carpenter Gothic character appears in the board-and-batten exterior walls and lancet windows, while the belfry centered above the altar area is unusual. The building was consecrated on March 17, 1883. Its construction and first services were closely connected to the Right Reverend Henry Benjamin Whipple, the first bishop of Minnesota, who began wintering in Maitland in the 1870s and led regular services each winter for the rest of his life.
A modern church designed by Nils M. Schweizer was added in 1967, and the original building became the chapel. On March 28, 2011, the 1880 church entered the National Register of Historic Places. The two buildings give Good Shepherd a worship setting that is both architecturally distinctive and suited to its continuing Sunday rhythm.
Biblical Faith and a Mission of Grace
Good Shepherd describes itself as biblical and affirms the Nicene and Apostles' Creeds. It believes that Jesus Christ is Lord and Savior, the Good Shepherd who laid down his life for everyone. Its statement of faith affirms God the Father as creator, the incarnation and work of Christ, the Holy Spirit, the church and communion of saints, forgiveness, resurrection, and everlasting life. The Bible is understood as the perfect, authoritative, life-giving Word of God that leads people to the living Jesus.
The mission is simple: Glorify God, gather people, and feed them with His grace. Another expression of the same purpose is revealing God's love and spreading that love to others. The Rev. Dr. Nathanael Saint-Pierre serves as rector. His ministry has included parish leadership, community development, preaching, pastoral care, congregational development, justice, reconciliation, and inclusion. A native of Haiti with experience in Haiti, Canada, the United States, and Tanzania, he holds a Doctor of Ministry in Homiletics from Bexley Seabury Seminary.
Sunday Formation, Wednesday Bible Study, and Free Outlines
Adult Christian formation takes several forms. Sunday classes meet from 9:30 to 10:15 a.m. in Roberta's Hall, with subjects that change from week to week. Wednesday Bible Study begins at 10:30 a.m., also in Roberta's Hall. Alpha explores the basics of Christian faith and life's big questions, while classes for Baptism, Confirmation, and First Communion are offered as needed.
The church also provides free teaching outlines used in its formation classes. They cover the Gospels of Luke and John, Hebrews, James, I and II Peter, the Psalms of David, the life of David, and the trial of Jesus. The resources are intended to reduce preparation time for Bible study or small groups and to support personal study as well.
Prayer, Licensed Visitors, and the Parish Table
Pastoral care is organized through a prayer team, licensed lay Eucharistic visitors, and periodic forums on subjects such as hospice, elder care, and caring for a caregiver. The prayer team meets online periodically with the rector and is present around the 10:30 a.m. Eucharist. Lay visitors bring Communion to people who cannot attend services, and funeral receptions are provided in Roberta's Hall or the Parish Hall after a loved one's funeral.
Fellowship meals are woven into the parish rhythm. A breakfast is served at 9:00 a.m. in Sarah's Hall, with a full-cooked breakfast on the first Sunday of each month and continental breakfast on other Sundays. The year also brings an annual parish meeting and potluck, an Easter Day brunch, Good Shepherd Sunday lunch, and Christmas carols and lunch.
The Food Pantry, Handmade Comforts, and Global Mission
The Good Shepherd Food Pantry distributes food and hygiene items to anyone in need on the second and fourth Saturdays of each month, from 9:00 to 11:00 a.m. Emergency bags of food are also available whenever the church office is open, usually Monday through Thursday from 9:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. The pantry's history reaches to Cornelia Whipple, wife of Bishop Henry Whipple, who began helping Seminole neighbors in Eatonville in 1883.
Tabitha's Treasures meets Tuesdays from 10:00 to 11:30 a.m. in the Prayer Room. The group knits, crochets, or looms chemo caps and prayer shawls, which are blessed during Sunday services and distributed to hospitals and chemotherapy centers. Good Shepherd also supports Good Shepherd Academy in Juba, South Sudan, through prayer and financial assistance. The school, run by Fr. John Daau, has about 500 students in kindergarten through seventh grade.
Angel Tree, Pet Blessings, and Service Beyond Maitland
The Angel Tree ministry collects toys and other gifts during Advent for children who might otherwise go without. Most of the gifts are distributed through OCPS social workers. Each year in October, a pet blessing takes place in the courtyard, adding a familiar community ritual to the church's calendar.
Alongside the food pantry, school support, handmade ministry, and seasonal giving, Good Shepherd sustains a broad network of church life. Its work extends from the prayer room and worship spaces to Eatonville, South Sudan, hospitals, and chemotherapy centers, connecting worship and parish fellowship with practical forms of care.
Stewardship of Buildings, Grounds, and Repairs
Parish stewardship combines financial support with hands-on care of the property. The parish encourages annual pledges. Committees tend the landscape, maintain the St. Francis Memorial Garden, organize workdays, and handle the church's extensive maintenance needs, from HVAC and roofs to plumbing, lighting, security, windows, and playground equipment. Fundraising efforts have included a Spaghetti Dinner and Basket Auction and a Chili Cook-off and Dessert Auction. Forward in Faith is a three-year capital campaign for needed repairs.
Giving can be made online through the church's online giving form.
Taken together, Good Shepherd's life joins a fixed Sunday rhythm with long-running service: worship in an 1880 chapel and a modern church, formation for adults, care around the altar and at tables, and hands-on outreach that began in 1883. That combination of worship, formation, care, fellowship, and service remains the center of life at Good Shepherd.