Carmel United Methodist Church sits in the heart of Carmel, Indiana, and is known for pairing traditional worship with an active mission in the city and Hamilton County. Its roots reach to 1851. During the school year, Sunday brings two traditional services in the sanctuary and one contemporary service in the Family Life Center, while the same congregation reaches outward through a food pantry, coat closet, preschool, children's ministries, housing partnerships and global mission work. The result is a church life that connects worship, formation and service.
Two Traditional Services and One Contemporary Service
Sunday worship at Carmel UMC is organized around three choices. Lead Pastor Tim Burchill leads each service, while the music, teaching style and physical setting create distinct forms of participation.
Traditional Worship at 9:00 and 10:30
Traditional worship is held at 9:00 a.m. and 10:30 a.m. in the sanctuary. Burchill's teaching is grounded in Biblical scripture, and the music includes hymns, the chancel choir, organ and piano. From late May through early August, the congregation combines these into one traditional service at 10:30 a.m.
Contemporary Worship in the Family Life Center
The 10:45 a.m. contemporary service takes place in the Family Life Center. Its music comes from the praise band, its teaching remains grounded in Biblical teachings, and the atmosphere is described as casual and friendly. The different setting and musical style give congregants a clear alternative to the traditional services without separating them from the same mission and congregation.
Door 3: A Welcome Center for First-Time Visitors
Visitors enter through the Welcome Center just inside south-facing door #3, where the drive runs under the portico. Welcoming volunteers can help with finding Sunday School, childcare and other questions. Coffee, tea and doughnuts are available at 10:00 a.m. in the Gathering Place Cafe. The church office is at 621 S. Range Line Road and is open Monday through Thursday from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
The 9:00 a.m. traditional service and the 10:45 a.m. contemporary service are livestreamed, with separate sanctuary and Family Life Center camera feeds. The 10:30 a.m. traditional service is not carried by video. Archived services can be watched later in the day or later in the week, and Facebook Live is another viewing option. Additional visitor information is available through the church's visitor information, while the livestream includes the current camera feeds and archived options.
Children Begin in Worship, Then Move to Sunday School
The children's ministry, led by Shaina Murphy, has a stated purpose of reaching children for the glory of God and giving them a firm foundation. Its teaching combines biblical learning with games, arts and crafts, while also involving parents in discipling children through time together in God's word and the example of daily life.
Sunday School serves children from three years of age through fifth grade. During the 10:30 a.m. traditional service, children begin in worship with their parents and are dismissed after the children's moment. Parents collect them from their classrooms after the service. Families attending the 10:45 a.m. contemporary service take their children directly to classrooms before worship; the children return for the final 10 to 15 minutes to rejoin their families. Children are signed in and out at the front desk.
Infants and toddlers receive professional, loving care during the 9:00, 10:30 and 10:45 services. Older children can also participate in the choir, games, arts and crafts, biblical lessons and other activities designed to make church a safe and engaging place for them.
For students in sixth through twelfth grades, Rick Belbutoski leads a youth ministry that partners with parents to help teenagers become mature disciples through relationships and purposeful activities. Middle and high school students meet for Youth Group from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. on Sunday evenings for food, activities and faith. Mission trips, service opportunities and volunteer roles extend that relationship beyond the regular gathering. Vacation Bible School preparation is another way adults can support the ministry of children.
A Christ-Centered Preschool in the Heart of Carmel
Carmel United Methodist Church Preschool is directed by Stephanie Holl, with Paula Foster serving as assistant director. The school seeks to nurture a love of learning in a joyful, safe and Christ-centered environment. Teachers work together to provide developmentally appropriate, play-based learning aligned with Department of Education standards. Inquiry-based play helps children explore ideas while learning with peers and developing social and emotional skills.
The preschool serves children from 18 months through the year before kindergarten, with schedules designed for each age:
- The Bunnies class is for children who are 18 months old and turning two. These young preschoolers meet twice a week for singing, dancing and play.
- The Ducks class is for children who are two and turning three. Children explore letters, numbers, shapes and colors through multisensory activities and meet three days a week.
- The 3's classes meet three days a week and combine gross-motor play, fine-motor play and social, emotional and academic learning. Children in these classes must be fully potty trained.
- The 4's classes meet Monday through Thursday and build skills that support a successful transition into elementary school.
- Alternative Kindergarten is designed for children who are five and offers an additional year of social and academic preparation before kindergarten. It meets Monday through Thursday.
All preschool classes meet from 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. The preschool's combination of Christian faith, play-based learning and sustained attention to social development makes it both a school and an extension of the church's ministry to young families.
Music for Every Generation and Every Service
David Morton directs the Music Ministry, whose purpose is to give glory to God through music. The ministry serves worship through numerous ensembles while also extending music beyond the church through concerts and community events. Opportunities are available for children, youth and adults, as well as for instrumentalists, singers and readers.
- The Chancel Choir rehearses Wednesdays from 6:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. during the school year and meets at 8:30 a.m. on Sundays to review music. It sings for the 9:00 and 10:30 services and welcomes people who cannot commit every week through seasonal opportunities.
- The Children's Choir includes children ages four through fifth grade. It rehearses Sundays from 10:00 a.m. to 10:30 a.m. and performs at the 10:30 and 10:45 services on second Sundays, with some exceptions.
- Sanctuary Handbells rehearse Wednesdays from 5:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. and take part in worship approximately once a month. The group welcomes people with handbell or music-reading experience.
- Acclaim! is a vocal quintet that rehearses Wednesdays from 5:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. during the school year. Its repertoire ranges from gospel to jazz, and it sings for both traditional services.
- The Contemporary Praise Band leads the 10:45 service. Members rehearse at 9:00 a.m. on Sundays and prepare music throughout the week according to their own schedules.
This variety allows music to serve both the structure of traditional worship and the relaxed atmosphere of the contemporary service while giving congregants of different ages meaningful ways to participate.
Adult Discipleship Built Around Relationship
Pastor Jessica Stevens serves as Connections Minister and Director of Adult Discipleship. The phrase building discipleship is relational shapes this ministry, whose leaders want to meet adults for coffee, listen to their lives and consider how the church can walk with them. Small groups and Bible studies are central to that approach, helping adults build relationships while growing in faith.
- The Prayer Shawl Circle meets on Tuesdays. Knitters and crocheters make prayer shawls for people in the church who need to be surrounded with prayer, and yarn is available for those who do not bring their own.
- An adult group meets on Wednesday mornings at 10:00 a.m.
- Another adult group meets on Thursday mornings at 11:30 a.m.
The church library keeps a collection of current books and recommended studies that adults can check out. Members may also request free access to RightNowMedia, which provides Bible studies, devotionals and other resources for adults and children.
Food for Hamilton County, from Pantry to Garden
Carmel UMC's mission ministry focuses on food insecurity, children and housing. Each focus connects local action with relationships that extend beyond the congregation.
A Food Pantry Serving About 300 Families
The Carmel food pantry serves about 300 families each month. Each household may visit once every month and must bring photo identification and proof of residence, such as a utility bill or rental agreement. The pantry provides healthy food to Hamilton County residents through the food pantry, community donations and fresh produce from the church's food pantry garden. Local churches and school organizations contribute to that supply, and Orchard Park Presbyterian Church donates all of the eggs distributed to pantry guests.
Volunteers are essential to the pantry's operation. New volunteers begin with training shifts from 5:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. on Tuesdays or 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. on Saturdays before serving as guest shoppers. The donation closet accepts food, toiletries, feminine products, dish soap and paper grocery bags. Volunteers also tend the food pantry gardens, whose produce continues the church's effort to grow nutritious food for the community.
Carmel UMC also partners with Roberts Park UMC in downtown Indianapolis for Soup's On, a Sunday meal served from noon to 1:00 p.m. for people who are hungry or homeless. Meals and personal hygiene items are provided, and Carmel UMC volunteers serve several times each year. Support also comes through to-go meals, peanut butter and jelly sandwich preparation, dignity items, backpacks and woven plastic mats made to keep people without homes warm.
Coats, Blankets, School Supplies and Foster Care
The Carmel Coat Closet works directly with Carmel Clay Schools, school counselors and social workers to reach children who need winter clothing. Coats and other gear are distributed through giveaways and school-level support that continues throughout winter. The ministry has also established a closet at the high school so students can obtain clothing during the school year. Local school relationships help identify needs, while the church's youth group has helped stock the closet with coats, hats, gloves, hoodies, shoes and backpacks. Collection workdays include sorting and organizing coats and assembling toiletry kits.
Bags of Hope assembles monogrammed duffel bags for children entering foster care. Each bag contains books, blankets, toys and other items chosen to bring comfort and joy. The related Blanket Ministry produces more than 500 single-layer fleece blankets each year for these bags.
Carmel UMC works with the Salvation Army on the Angel Tree, hosting the program in the Family Life Center and guiding families through the process of selecting gifts for children. The congregation also supports Sierra Leone through Operation Classroom. Its partnership with schools including Taiama Enterprise Academy provides school supplies, scholarships and room and board so more children can have access to education.
Housing, Meals and Home Repair
Family Promise is an organization dedicated to preventing and ending family homelessness. Carmel UMC was one of the founding partner churches when the nonprofit began in the Indianapolis area. What began with churches providing food and winter shelter grew into efforts to furnish apartments with the stability and necessities families need to establish a home.
Each year, a Carmel UMC team travels to Frakes, Kentucky, through Henderson Settlement to work on home improvement projects for families. The work includes building and improving decks and making other repairs that can strengthen a home and renew hope. The church also responds to disasters through relief efforts such as support for flood relief in Central Indiana.
Connecting, Growing and Serving as Disciples
The vision of Carmel United Methodist Church is to connect with God and others, grow in faith and love through Biblical learning, and serve the community and world as followers of Jesus Christ. As a United Methodist congregation, its mission is to make disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world. The Bible is described as the blueprint for life, and the church emphasizes learning its teachings, engaging in fellowship and using personal passions and talents in service.
Pastor Tim Burchill describes Carmel UMC as a Wesleyan, grace-led church. In his teaching, grace does not make people independent or self-contained. Grace makes people connected, so that the grace received from God through other people can then become a channel of grace reaching others.
Six core values express that vision:
- We don't do life alone.
- Grateful hearts fuel graceful worship.
- Growth is not optional.
- Found people find people.
- Blessed people bless people.
- Saved people serve people.
Together, these values say that people need community, gratitude, growth, good news, opportunities to bless others and a purpose larger than themselves. Carmel UMC places its confidence in the grace of Jesus Christ as the answer to those needs.
Baptism, Weddings and Funerals
Baptism is understood as belonging, marking entry into the Christian faith community and the body of Christ. Carmel UMC practices both infant and adult baptism for infants, children, youth and adults. Baptism is celebrated during public worship, with pre-baptism counseling offered by the pastors. United Methodists do not practice re-baptism.
Christian marriage is regarded as a covenant undertaken in the sight of God with the intent of establishing a relationship responsive to God. Church membership is expected for couples preparing for marriage, and the bride, groom or an immediate family member must be a member. A Carmel UMC pastor officiates the ceremony, with other pastors able to assist at the officiating pastor's invitation.
A Christian funeral is described as the final celebration of a faithful disciple of Jesus Christ and an act of worship. Funeral services may take place in the sanctuary, chapel, at a graveside or in a funeral home. Memorial services can also be arranged in the sanctuary or chapel, and the organist can provide music for funerals and memorials held in the church's facilities.
People who wish to join formally can attend new member classes, which are generally offered in spring and fall. New members are then formally welcomed by the congregation during worship.
A Place for Every Kind of Service
Volunteering at Carmel UMC follows the same broad mission that shapes worship and discipleship. Service roles include:
- Welcoming visitors as greeters, Welcome Center hosts and hosts for coffee and doughnuts.
- Assisting in worship as ushers, liturgists, worship leaders, Communion servers, choir members, band members and members of the worship space team.
- Serving on the technical crew for sound, slides and cameras.
- Teaching or assisting in Sunday School and the youth Encounter and Reconnect groups.
- Supporting the food pantry, food pantry gardens, Harvest Food Bank, Gleaners and Soup's On.
- Preparing for Vacation Bible School, collecting coats, assembling Bags of Hope, supporting the Angel Tree and contributing to Operation Classroom in Sierra Leone.
- Working with Family Promise, Henderson Settlement and other housing missions.
- Helping with childcare, event hosting, office support, communications, social media and community events such as the Carmel Marathon and Carmel Winter Games.
Giving That Supports the Work of the Church
Giving can be made online as a one-time or recurring gift through a checking account, debit card or credit card. Congregants can also text CARMELUMC to 77977 or place cash or checks in offering envelopes during worship. The church's giving options also support designated funds, including missions.
The Endowment Fund manages and invests bequest gifts, then distributes investment income according to each donor's intent. This structure allows gifts to support Carmel UMC's ministry and mission beyond the original gift, creating a lasting contribution tied to the donor's wishes.
Since 1851, Carmel United Methodist Church has continued to gather for biblical learning, worship, music, fellowship and service. Its work reaches from Carmel into Hamilton County, Indianapolis and Sierra Leone through food, clothing, education, housing and home repair. Carmel UMC remains a church organized around one continuing movement: connecting with God and others, growing in faith and love, and serving the community and world.